Pure Joyce

The reading is magnificent. Through the crowded pages and episodes of literally hundreds of characters, the narrator, John Lee, manages to catch in all their tones, quirks, and color the distinct voices of each. His inflection, pitch, and cadence is clear and deadly accurate. Not only are the rolling rhythms of Joyce's prose maintained with uncanny naturalness--thoughts are recognizable as such (not merely rendered as captioned overlays) and the tones, timbres, moods, and motives of the enormous flood of speech are rendered in as richly and varied accents as they would if one were walking the streets of Dublin.

From heavy Latinate meditations to the onomatopoeic replication of linotype machines in the newspaper office and the raucous imitation of a gramophone recording of a deceased grandfather, Lee's renderings are palpably believable as both the realities they represent and, more importantly, as empathetic interpretations of the individual hearts and minds they issue from.

I was first a bit wary of the lower cost and ratings of this version compared with the nearly tripled price of the most reviewed recording (who knows what they were thinking), but after listening to the provided sample of its long stretches of rushed and flattened monotone and hokey interpolated music recordings, I moved on to find this gem. It does what Joyce's greatest gift does--bring the full panorama of humanity to life purely through language.

34 persone l'hanno trovata utile

A forceful narration but a long haul

This is James Joyce fired out of a cannon. An impressive demonstration of narrative athleticism by the talented John Lee does not compensate for a lengthy difficult listen and lack of nuance. It may possibly have been compressed in post production on the other hand to squeeze it into a certain time frame in which case they should de-compress it and re-publish. The nuance might bloom once it has air. 60% speed should do it. Then you might have a great audio.

16 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Incomprehensible

I give Joyce credit for trying something new and perhaps in written form this book might be interesting but as an audio book, I found it to be completely incomprehensible. I had absolutely no idea what was going on even after I went to Wikipedia to read their summary as I was going along. For the first time ever, I have given up on a book. I got about 10 hours into it but it became drudgery to try to keep up with what was going on. I found myself zoning out and rewinding all the time. I wish I could say I loved this book as the other reviewers have but it was way too far out for me.

Perhaps most disappointing was that I love John Lee so much but even his performance was mediocre and could not save this book. He does an admirable job with his Irish accent but it was so thick I couldn't understand much of it.

I cannot recommend this book unless you already know the story, are from Ireland and are on some kind of hallucinogenic. Otherwise, it was all gobbledygook to me.

14 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Marathon Man

Would you listen to Ulysses again? Why?

This is a once in a lifetime experience -- I would never be able to sit down and read the book, but hearing the voices, those Irish voices, internal and external, as the history of the world filters through the events and consciousness of a single day in Dublin, expands the sense of what is possible in language. Younger and older language artists, Daedalus and Bloom, survive debauchery and humiliation, contemplating, absorbing, reacting to the death of a mother, the infidelity of a wife, the centrifugal and centripetal forces from home. Obscurity and arcaneness to a modern reader melt away in the wash and ocean of mesmerizing sound and language.

What does John Lee bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?

I heard John Lee read Orhan Pahmuk's Snow and couldn't place his exotic sounding accent which seemed perfect for that book. But to hear him read Ulysses is to know that this is what he was born to do, that Irish voice, that Irish soul.

Any additional comments?

This is a mammoth undertaking.

12 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Not for Everyone

Would you try another book from James Joyce and/or John Lee?

James Joyce is an acquired taste as far as I can figure. It would depend on the person whether I would recommend it. John Lee would be perfectly fine on something that wasn't so *completely* taxing and mind-numbingly difficult.

What did you like best about this story?

I rather did like that there was stream-of-consciousness and alliterative prose, but not to the extent it happened in this book. I know that Joseph Campbell read this book 56 times, bless him, but I can't see getting through it once. (I got two thirds through)

Would you listen to another book narrated by John Lee?

Oh yes.

If this book were a movie would you go see it?

Maybe.

Any additional comments?

Having it audio did help me a bit getting through the stream-of-consciousness way that it is written. Hearing expressed in a voice is quite a bit easier than trying to interpret it as text, as happened in the last Joyce book I tried to read. So if a person was keen to read a Joyce book having an audio book is helpful if it is hard for them. The whispersync might even be better, but I can't say for sure.

4 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Impossible to follow the Irish accent and I tried.

Any additional comments?

I really wanted to get this classic under my belt, but found that it was just too complicated for my busy mind and knew that I would not get used to it even if I were to persist. Perhaps I will come back to it when I have time to concentrate really hard for 100% of the time. Others may well love it and the language was delightful in the sample but not for more than an hour of my busy day. I wish I could say more.

4 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Perfect

Would you recommend this audiobook to a friend? If so, why?

If one only gives up on understanding every little thing about this book (an impossible, tedious and no doubt boring task), one would enjoy a funny, intelligent and inspiring masterpiece.

3 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Narration could have used better direction

Any additional comments?

A fantastic novel and at times the narration is perfect. The last two chapters especially are great. Unfortunately the lack of indication when a chapter starts is a serious drawback. Lee does a great job bringing out the accents and Dubliness of this book though.

3 persone l'hanno trovata utile

So immensely Irish. So mesmerizing and vivid.

I've read this book at high school to feel myself modern and educated and I sort of struggled to the end. I must notice that proper narrator changes things dramatically. John Lee is the king amongst narrators indeed.

2 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Brisk

John Lee gives a brisk and engaging reading of this difficult book.

I listened to it again recently, and I have to mention something I failed to note when I first posted this review. He gives a particularly fine reading of Molly Bloom’s soliloquy. It’s a two-hour monologue with (if I remember correctly) only three punctuation marks in the print edition. The sentences pour out fast and furious, and it requires some concentration, but Lee’s reading makes sense of the individual phrases AND the overall sweep of emotion, ending on a wonderfully triumphant note. His version of the soliloquy isn’t an uninflected recital; it has a shape. Some recordings have a woman reading this part, and while that may be better, I don’t think it’s really a problem here: it is, after all, a man’s fantasy of what goes through a woman’s mind.

In an earlier release of this audiobook, the narration ran all the episodes together without a break. Since each episode has a distinctive style, this quickly became confusing. Fortunately the publisher has fixed this: the episodes are now clearly separated by a pause of several seconds. It's a small change (maybe not small from a technical standpoint, but to the listener), but it makes a world of difference.

As with any other reading of Ulysses, it helps to have a guidebook at hand. I think this is even more important than having the text itself. A guide like Blamires’ New Bloomsday Book will keep you oriented and explain the most important references.

2 persone l'hanno trovata utile