Anthropologists in Love

Euphoria presents a classic love triangle among three anthropologists in New Guinea between the world wars. The main charcter is Nell Stone, modeled after Margaret Mead, a free-thinking, insightful, deeply empathetic student of native cultures. Her husband Fen is her opposite, cynical, greedy and dismissive of local sentiments. Between them comes Bankson, the narrator, looking back years later on their brief time together in a small village, trying to control their lusts but not their ambitions. The story is well told, more absorbing and suspenseful as the book progresses. The author, like Nell, has a quick feel for other characters. Minor characters are well drawn with a few telling details. You especially feel for several of the villagers whose lives are changed by their observers.

The audiobook has a serious flaw, namely, the drab narration by Simon Vance. Bankson should be an energetic, passionate, vibrant young force of nature, despite his failed suicide attempt at the novel's start. Instead, Vance reads as a depressed and weary old man. This drains the novel of much of its excitement. Xe Sands, reading as Nell Stone, is far better, with the right enthusiasm and wonder in her voice. Overall, however, this was an excellent book.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

79 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Excellent story, couldn't stop reading!

This was one of those rare books that I couldn't put down from the minute I started it and couldn't stop reading till I had finished three days later. As a temperamental reader, I seldom find books these days that enchant me right from the first page and never let me drift off. The story was fantastic, the plot never rested, but the characters were fully drawn and kept you deeply engaged in their fate and in the things for which they were passionate - in this case their anthropological work.

It is a story about a character inspired by Margaret Mead and it follows her into tribal settings along with her very new husband and his very aggressive personality, jealousy and inability to imagine his life as her spouse rather than vice versa. A third anthropologist encounters them during their Sepic river studies and the trio's balance is upset by the tensions. Tragedy ensues. But how you get there is an intricate and fascinating path through tribal studies and the ecstasy, the euphoria, of thinking you are coming to understand some part of human nature up close.

The book was an intellectual adventure in addition to a well-told tale.

What is unusual for me is that I was not so happy with the audio version, despite the male reader, Simon Vance who is one of my favorite readers of all time - I kid you not I once actually wrote him 'fan mail' to let him know how much I had enjoyed his versions of the Anthony Trollope Barsetshire novels. Yet his reading didn't click for me in this narration, and I especially didn't enjoy having two different narrators - a male for the Bankson narration in the book and a female for the Nell Stone narration. It also wasn't consistent, since each narrator then had to read parts of all the characters in that section of the book - so you had two VERY different characterizations of the Australian accent for Fen.

Since I had purchased both the Kindle and Audible versions, I just finished the book entirely on the Kindle, although I had planned to alternate between the two. I think it's fair to conclude I prefer one continuous narrator for a novel and will think about that issue the next time I am presented with a choice.

Highly recommended novel whichever way you choose to hear it or read it - I look forward to reading Lily King's earlier novels.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

65 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Sad

The majority of the story was sad, especially the ending. Don’t care for books where women are abused by their husbands.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

44 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Boring, Depressing

Long stretches contemplating death, disease, and dying punctuated by colonial wasps drinking and having meaningless sex. If you love ennui, this one's for you.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

43 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Fascinating and absorbing

A beautifully-written and compelling book about fascinating people. The anthropologists are as interesting as the tribes they are studying. I could have gone on listening to this for quite a while longer and am sorry it's over. I completely disagree with the reviewers who panned Simon Vance. No, his reading of Bankson isn't euphoric, but neither is Bankson's character. So much of what is going on in the book is in the contrast between his approach and that of Nell and Fen, and Simon Vance and Xe Sands (whom I also loved) nailed this aspect. Great book, great narration all around. I loved it.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

32 persone l'hanno trovata utile

BORING

Any additional comments?

Thank God for "Mom from Mercer." Thought I was out of it. Have a Minor in Anthropology, love Margaret Mead, and think this book is slow, dull, and mankind would die out if this were real romance.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

29 persone l'hanno trovata utile

The story you think you know is never the real one

This is such a powerful book. A breathtaking tale of three Anthropologists studying tribes in New Guinea, in the 1930’s, it’s history when there were still discoveries made on this planet. Based loosely on the lives of Margaret Mead and her second and third husband, the love triangle develops into an intense character study that will have you feeling for each person at more than one point. The underlying tension that the author builds within the story is outstanding. I also liked how she was able to use small antidotes and scenes to paint whole pictures. The short sex scene in the first chapter just lays out every single thing you need to know about this couple’s marriage. What an extremely talented author.

I thought the audiobook was just a perfect means to tell this story. I enjoyed both of the narrators personally.

I can’t imagine a better, more surprising ending. I re-listened to the last several chapters several times because I was just so surprised by it.

If you were on MY Christmas list - you would alllll be getting this book.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

28 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Since when has domestic violence been sexy?

A story about domestic violence, a whinny friend and giving cigarettes to the natives for information. The writing was good. The narration is OK, but there are some rough edit locations.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

26 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Great story, one poor reader, one good one

Would you try another book from Lily King and/or Simon Vance and Xe Sands ?

By Lily King and Xe Sands, yes! But Simon Vance-/ a very prolific audible reader -- is pedantic, boring and supercilious. I will not listen to a book read by him again. He sounds like an ex Shakesperian actor who thinks he sounds great, but us really really boring! He makes me zone out. Luckily Xe Sands was great and so I was able to finish an excellent story.

What other book might you compare Euphoria to and why?

State of Wonder-- similar anthropological bent and riveting details about other cultures, with interesting characters.

Who would you have cast as narrator instead of Simon Vance and Xe Sands ?

Xe Sands was great. Anyone would have been better than Simon Vance for this listener.

If this book were a movie would you go see it?

Yes.

Any additional comments?

None.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

18 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Clever Pathos in Exotic Setting

This is one clever author. King creates a claustrophobic, small world in the vast tropical miasma of New Guinea. Andrew Bangston, whose loneliness is almost a fourth character in itself; brilliant and driven Nell Stone; Nell's lout of a husband Fen - these anthropologists are really the only three characters as the rest are set pieces and background.

King does a great job capturing the arrogance and indeed racism of early 20th C anthropologists - you do wonder what their subjects thought when these frail people plopped themselves into a village that had been peacefully minding its own business. Each anthropologists' approach is shaped by their own demons and biases, and the relationship between the three is glued together by Bangston's desparate loneliness.

The ending snuck up on me, which I appreciated. King had a way of making the reader think the book was about one thing, when it was really about something else.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

15 persone l'hanno trovata utile