Faith was four years old when she started singing “Our Song” everywhere we went.
The grocery store. The car. The little ice cream shop where the lady behind the counter thought she was the cutest thing she had ever seen.
She has been a Taylor Swift fan for as long as Taylor Swift has existed, and I have had a front-row seat watching my daughter grow up right alongside Taylor’s career.
So when we sat down in a coffee shop to plan our next XwhyZ episode, it was only a matter of time before we landed here.
Faith came in with a thesis, a notebook full of research, and a warning:
We have never been able to be normal about this woman.
Her argument is that Taylor was never really the underdog.
She has been a businesswoman since she was 16, running her own career in an industry built by and for men, while playing the girl next door who wears T-shirts and sits on the bleachers.
That gap between the relatable persona and the mogul is where a lot of our complicated feelings come from.
We loved her when she was humble, then got tired of her acting surprised.
We love her success, then bristle when she asks for more of it.
And then we got to the part where we actually disagreed.
Taylor Swift Is a Billionaire. Now What?
Taylor Swift is a billionaire.
Dolly Parton never was, because she gave so much of her money away.
Faith wants Taylor to put her name, and not just her money, behind a cause and ask her fans to follow her there.
I found myself defending her, which surprised both of us.
She’s 35. She just finished the biggest tour in music history.
And I keep coming back to the same question:
Why are women held to an impossible standard where success only counts if you give half of it away while championing 77 causes at the same time?
We don’t settle it.
That’s kind of the point.
Having complicated feelings about Taylor Swift feels a lot like having complicated feelings about a friend you grew up with.
You love them. You wish they’d do a few things differently. And you’re not going to feel the same way at 20 that you did at four.
And somewhere out there, a brand-new twelve-year-old is hearing “Fifteen” for the first time and thinking it was written just for her.
In This Episode
Faith and I talk about:
* Why Faith says Taylor Swift was never the underdog
* The Life of a Showgirl backlash, and why not everything has to be her best work
* The double-edged sword of being “relatable” as a young woman in the public eye
* Folklore, the pandemic, and the start of what Faith’s sister calls the Taylor Swift “mass psychosis”
* The $1 countersuit, and what it said about who she was at 21
* Political neutrality, great power, great responsibility, and whether that line belongs to Spider-Man or JFK
* Dolly Parton, billionaires, and whether Taylor owes her fans more than she’s giving
* The Gen X vs. Gen Z split on what we expect from the most famous woman in the world
This Week’s Wonder
Put on the Taylor Swift song that makes you dance around the kitchen.
Then find a charity you believe in and give it a little something.
Because maybe you don’t have to choose between enjoying someone’s success and expecting more from the people who have the power to make a difference.
What Should We Talk About Next?
Got a topic you want Faith and me to take on next?
Leave it in the comments or send us a message.
And if we got a fact wrong, please politely correct us.
Facts only, not our opinions. 😉
Get full access to Cristie Ritz-King, PsyD at critzking.substack.com/subscribe