The Moat Is Not the Software copertina

The Moat Is Not the Software

The Moat Is Not the Software

Ascolta gratuitamente

Vedi i dettagli del titolo

Offerte di stagione | 0,99 €/mese per i primi 3 mesi

A seguire 9,99 €/mese – si applicano condizioni. Puoi disdire mensilmente.
A proposito di questo titolo
Scott Larter runs BrokerBot on licensed Canadian property data, and he came to mortgage from the data side, at Opta, Verisk and FCT. Forty-four minutes in, he puts a three to five year clock on his own company's defensibility and names what he thinks is actually holding the door shut. Chris Grimes and Reuven Gorsht push on what is left to defend once a competitive analysis that used to take a team weeks takes twenty minutes and a coffee, and once the same intelligence sits in everybody's pocket. What the three of them land on is narrower than what the industry has been selling, and none of it is the software.Why AI is not a competitive advantage in mortgage techIn 2018 Scott Larter put a big orange booth on a trade show floor in Montreal, knew one person in the room, and was there to find out whether property data had any place in mortgage lending at all. Eight years later he runs BrokerBot, and he is arguing about a different question. What counts as a competitive advantage in mortgage tech now that the cost of building the product has fallen to almost nothing?Scott came to mortgage from the data side, at Opta, Verisk and FCT, which is why he treats a broker's client book as a dataset in an industry that has always treated it as a rolodex. He is talking to Chris Grimes and Reuven Gorsht, who between them have built a lending decisioning platform and a real estate closing business. This page sets out what the three of them worked through and which questions they left open. What they conclude is on the tape.WHY THERE ARE SUDDENLY HUNDREDS OF VENDORSReuven's framing is that the economics of starting a software company have inverted. When he started MoveSnap and when Chris started FundMore, you validated an idea hard first, because you were about to spend at least a million dollars in cash or in sweat equity. Now anybody can build a working prototype in an afternoon, so the constraint has moved.He brings a figure back from a panel of venture investors he sat in on a few weeks before recording. Their position was that they are still funding roughly the same number of deals a year that they always have, while the denominator underneath that number has grown by something like a hundredfold. Scott's experience points the same way from the other side of the table. In his data years he was approached by ten to twenty startups a year looking for Canadian property data to build on, and he is blunt that cheap Canadian property data does not exist in this country.Chris supplies the uncomfortable part. He argues that low adoption among lenders is not a temporary lag, that it has stayed low, and that a proof of concept which never reaches production is not evidence of anything. WHAT COUNTS AS A COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE IN MORTGAGE TECH NOWReuven's answer begins by taking something away, in one flat sentence that is the most quotable line on the tape. What he says is left afterwards sits in two places. The first is distribution, meaning a network or a community you can actually put a product in front of. The second is the judgment to know which output is any good, which he ties to twenty-five years of knowing which advertisement is off message and which one will get you in trouble with a regulator.Scott gives the clearest worked example. He ran a competitive analysis across the Canadian and US markets and turned it into a deck for his team, and he puts a figure on how long that took against the weeks it used to take. A moat is not a moat if it can be replicated, and that today almost everything can be. You can point a model at a competitor and have it decompose what they are doing in fifteen minutes.He also raises the problem nobody in the industry enjoys looking at. When you feed your own working into a general purpose tool, you may be sharpening the thing a competitor uses against you next quarter. He puts it as a question, because he does not have the answer either.THE END OF THE PURE PRODUCT COMPANYScott asks the hosts a direct question about their own businesses. If a junior person with some AI ability can now build internally, for a salary, what a vendor charges in licensing, does that change how a lender evaluates products like theirs?Chris gives ground immediately and says that it will. Then he draws a line, and where he draws it is the argument of this section. He does not think vendors get wiped out. He thinks the pure product company stops existing unless it owns one very specific problem in a very large space, and that what replaces it is a partner who brings most of the way and then works with the customer on the rest. He puts the split in proportions and calls the result a pivot toward services. Whether he is right is the thing to listen for.Reuven works the same idea through a different industry. He describes replacing an advertising agency brief with a Sunday morning and a model, and is precise about what he did not get, which was thirty years of agency expertise and somebody else carrying the ...
adbl_web_anon_alc_button_suppression_t1
Ancora nessuna recensione