⚠️ Trigger Warning: This episode contains discussions of kidnapping, sexual assault, and severe abuse.

This week on Should I Watch That?, Rachel and Janet tackle one of the most infamous true-crime cases in American history through the lens of the documentary Kidnapped: Elizabeth Smart.

We take you back to June 2002, when 14-year-old Elizabeth was taken from her bedroom in the middle of the night. We break down the deeply disturbing actions of her captors, Brian David Mitchell and Wanda Barzee, the agonizing missteps made by law enforcement, and the sheer will it took for Elizabeth to survive nine months in the wilderness under extreme manipulation.

Ultimately, this is a story of incredible survival. We discuss Elizabeth’s enduring strength, her grace, and her vital advocacy work today with the Elizabeth Smart Foundation. Listen in to hear our thoughts on the documentary, how it handles the subject matter, and whether it's a must-watch.

Resources mentioned in this episode:

• Elizabeth Smart Foundation: [Insert Link]

• RAINN National Sexual Assault Hotline: 1-800-656-HOPE (4673)

Join Janet and Rachel for a special Valentine's episode as they gush over the Netflix adaptation of Emily Henry’s best-selling novel, People We Meet On Vacation.

In this episode, the ladies break down the friends-to-lovers romance between the spontaneous Poppy (Emily Bader) and the buttoned-up Alex (Tom Blyth). From the undeniable on-screen chemistry to the hilarious "250 condoms" scene with Molly Shannon, find out why this movie melted their cold, dead hearts.

Tune in to hear why they’re giving this one a "double thumbs up" and why it might just be the best rom-com of the year!

This week on Should I Watch That?, Janet and Rachel tackle the 2026 buddy action-comedy The Wrecking Crew. Starring Jason Momoa as a loose-cannon cop and Dave Bautista as a disciplined Navy SEAL, the film follows two estranged half-brothers who must team up to solve their father's murder in Hawaii.

We discuss the film's fun, "non-serious" vibe, the genuine chemistry between the leads, and the standout supporting cast including Morena Baccarin and Stephen Root. Tune in to hear our thoughts on the wild fight choreography, the authentic (and sometimes funny) local flair, and whether this explosive family reunion is worth adding to your watchlist.

Key Topics:

• Momoa vs. Bautista: Analyzing the brother dynamic.

• Why we appreciated the film's lighter, comedic tone.

• A breakdown of the action sequences (and the injuries that realistically should have happened).

• Final rating: Should you watch that?

Links:

• Email us: shouldiwatchthat25@gmail.com

• Follow us on Instagram: @shouldiwatchthat25

• Follow us on Facebook: @shouldiwatchthat

Don't forget to like, follow, and review!

Must-Watch or Hard Pass? In this episode of Should I Watch That?, Janet and Rachel dive into the world of The Beauty. Is it a breathtaking masterpiece or just skin-deep? The ladies break down the plot, the performances, and—most importantly—answer the ultimate question so you don’t have to. Tune in for the honest, unfiltered take that only SIWT can provide.

• Janet and Rachel dive into the new Netflix thriller, "The Rip", starring the legendary duo Ben Affleck and Matt Damon. Is this a long-awaited reunion or a forgettable action flick?

• They break down the plot: Two Miami narcotics cops find $20 million in a cartel stash house and face the ultimate moral dilemma—report it or rip it? The hosts discuss the film's "true-ish story" inspiration, the intense chemistry between the leads, and whether the "bro-heavy" dialogue is a hit or a miss.

• Join them as they debate the central question: If you found a fortune in dirty money, would you take it? Tune in to find out if this one is worth your Friday night popcorn!

Join Janet and Rachel for a cozy holiday special! In this episode, we are counting down our absolute favorite Christmas movies of all time.

We aren't spoiling the list here—you’ll have to listen to find out which classics (and surprises) made the cut. Grab some cocoa, settle in, and see if your favorites match ours.

This week on Should I Watch That?, Janet and Rachel dive into the sticky, paranoid world of Yorgos Lanthimos’s latest sci-fi black comedy, Bugonia.

We’re breaking down the chaotic energy between Jesse Plemons (our favorite unhinged conspiracy theorist) and Emma Stone (the ice-cold corporate girlboss who might literally be a bug). Is this a sharp satire on how the internet broke our brains, or just two hours of screaming in a basement?

In this episode:

• The Vibe Check: Does this beat Poor Things on the weird-o-meter?

• The Plot: Why kidnapping your boss to save the bees is (probably) a bad HR move.

• The Verdict: Is the bleak ending brilliant or just a buzzkill?

Should you watch it? Tune in to find out if this one is worth the squeeze or if it should’ve stayed in the hive.

Rachel and Janet take on All’s Fair, a sharp, flirty courtroom dramedy where love, ego, and strategy collide. We start spoiler-light with the hook, chemistry between the leads, and whether the case-of-the-day structure serves the bigger story. Then we dig into craft—pace, banter, needle-drops, and how the script balances stakes with swoon—plus a look at direction and production design (yes, those wood-paneled courtrooms). After a clear spoiler wall, we unpack the third-act choices, final arguments, and what the ending says about winning versus being right.