Claysville psychiatrist Mark McCain is convinced he has discovered the presence of a vampire. He confronts Andrew Clayton, believing him to be the vampire, and they have a brief, tense conversation about his background and motives.

Andrew forbids Stanford from interacting with Mark. Mark questions Toby Clayton about the night Andrew arrived at Clayton Mill.

Holly Baumgartner guesses that Andrew is a vampire and tries to find out more about him.

Mark ponders why he is obsessed with Andrew. He is invited back for another conversation with Andrew, which is less strained, and both open up a bit more about themselves.

Mark allows Andrew to use mind control power on him. Andrew introduces Mark to Stanford Jameson, greatly disturbing and angering him.

Andrew despairs over Mark’s fury, and Holly suggests he call Mark and try to make amends.

Mark tries to reach out in peace to Stanford, but it does not go well. Mark refuses to forgive Andrew. Andrew finally opens up about the witch he is attempting to hide from.

Mark enlists the help of an old flame, Alison Simmons, to help Andrew protect himself from Gabrielle.