Oh gosh

I really should have read the reviews because other people have been here before me and could have saved me the time.

Don't come looking for a book of the quality of the Martian. It's not even close.

Don't come looking for a good story, it's predictable, has holes and is uninspiring.

But the killer, for me, is the author's view of how young women think. Wow. You should read the book to experience this.

On a positive note, loved the narrator and production.

59 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Awful protagonist

Author cannot write from a woman's perspective in my opinion. The character is sex-quip obsessed, and apparently the harlot of the moon.
Hats off to the narrator for giving it her all, she did a fantastic job of keeping me going for 2 hours but I gave up. Honestly, Jas isn't a nice person. I feel no empathy for her, and she is a 15 year old boy in her inner monologue.

Andy Weir, please. We don't need a sex reference every other sentence.

14 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Rubbish - minor spoilers in this review.

Oh heck, was looking forward to this, but it’s just utter tripe.

So, she’s a delivery girl, who’s just been asked to commit a major act of sabotage by someone who she delivers contraband cigars to. She’s taken some electronic plans to a fellow genius and he’s amazed she’s drawn these up overnight. He agrees to build whatever thing she’s designed, but only if she’ll test some re-usable condoms he’s just crested. She agrees. Off to see her dad who she doesn’t really get on with to borrow some welding equipment.

None of this makes sense! The central character is just a childish fantasy from the mind of a 12 year old. The other characters we’ve met so far also seem to be conjured from the same 12 year old mind. I can’t finish it, I bought it in a 2 for 1 sale so doubt I can return it for my credit back.

Yet another book from audible that fails to live up to the hype and certain glowing reviews.

11 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Jazzed Up Sci-Fi Crime Caper

As The Martian Mark Watney was a real star of a character, his struggles and internal monologues really brought his whole situation to light. He was one of the elite, in the space program and with multiple degrees to his name. Jazz is the same in that she also indulges her narrative in the same low humour but she's progressed a lot less and through rather more dubious routes. If you buy into her you'll likely buy into the story.

This is a fast-moving sci-fi crime caper that gets increasingly out of control as it goes along. It's fun, it's laden with interesting science which I won't try to validate because cleverer than me people are still debating The Martian! I do think Weir lets himself go just a bit more with this one and the final part of the adventure does stretch things a bit but not any more than many authors do.

I'm quite shocked, genuinely, to read some early critical reviews of the narration. I think Dawson is an absolute star in this. She delivers Jazz pretty much perfectly for me and the other characters are easily distinguishable. If you have doubts listen to the audio sample of course and come to your own decision but I'd definitely recommend giving it a chance and not being put off even trying!

So, maybe not quite the all-time classic that The Martian was with of course the great RC Bray but definitely a highly entertaining read if you like this style of humour. Sure, the story has some weaknesses but I still found it thoroughly entertaining.

87 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Very weak. Poor plot, poor central character

What did you like best about Artemis? What did you like least?

Great voice performance, some interesting ideas about the moon base itself.

Really good voice performance by Rosario Dawson, she makes the most of the weak material.

What was most disappointing about Andy Weir’s story?

This is a very immature book, with a plot filled with holes and truly hopeless characters. The choice of language and speech patterns for the lead character are like a middle aged mans idea of how a "sexy young woman" would talk.

Only a man could write a female character like the lead.

She's like a Tesco Value Mark Watney, with needless sexual elements shoe horned into the text in a clumsy manner.

The plot itself is very weak too, failing to stand up to the most rudimentary application of critical thought.

You can see the benefits that Andy Weir had from the long development and continual peer review of "The Martian". none of which is demonstrated in this. The best use I can think of for this book is as an example of why writing a character from a totally different culture/background to yourself is very hard to get right, and painful to read when you get it this wrong.

Do you think Artemis needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?

Absolutely not.

43 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Hmmm...

Written from a female perspective but is tone deaf in the details; reads more like a male fantasy of the way that a woman thinks and there are some really cringey bits. So...she is a hot, genius, welding, space engineer, smuggler, sci-fi tv geek, who can turn her hand to literally anything and has a smokin’ body: it just got really annoying to read someone’s teenage fantasy of a cool woman rather than a nuanced, developed character.
I loved his first book but this one just drove me crazy and the plot was rather dull, because an arsehole (sorry: anti hero) attempting to commit a crime is not as gripping as someone trying to save their own life by escaping from an impossible situation.
The narration was good - Dawson gave the character as much credibility as she could.

187 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Standing on the shoulder of The Martian

This didn’t work for me. Not the detail of his previous work and the voice actor just didn’t connect. Poor.

30 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Simply amazing! You won't regret this one!

Absolutely amazing, captivating and clever. The way wier creates worlds and characters is really something and the story keeps you gripped throughout

4 persone l'hanno trovata utile

A book about living in a vacuum that doesn't suck.

I don't get why some people have been giving this only one star. Yes the main character has many failings. However the storyline is compelling and the last half of the book I could barely put down. To be honest I am now hoping for a sequel...

28 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Not as good as The Martian

It was ok, but The Martian casts a large shadow, it’s hard not to compare premise, realism, narration, humour, protagonist etc and find Artemis lacking.

I likely expected too much, but hoped for science fiction that didn’t lean on the tropes of distant future technology/infrastructure - no matter how well backed by scientific theory - when the authors previous work had tapped into the realisation that an amazing story can be told without too much hand waving, and leaves the audience believing the authors world is one they could live to see and be in.

24 persone l'hanno trovata utile