We’re wrapping up the year by turning When Girls Talk Books into a full-blown gameshow 🎤📚
With Connor running producer-led trivia, we tally our quirks, rate hot takes, and relive the moments that made us cry-laugh this year. Then we race through a lightning-round fancast and start planning bookish field trips — including a hockey romance read paired with a live game.

This episode is chaotic, nostalgic, and very on-brand.

In this episode:
• producer-led trivia on phrases and ratings
• the infamous one-star reveal and why it stuck
• Grave Matters vs Roses in Rome highlights
• summer callbacks and the tennis ball saga
• rank-the-phrases challenge (and what it says about us)
• lightning-round fancasts across multiple books
• future bookish outings + a hockey romance plan
• listener invites to share top picks and favorite tropes

🎧 If you love book podcasts, trivia games, and friends talking books, this one’s for you.

Let us know in the comments:
👉 which book moment lived rent-free in your head
👉 your favorite trope of the year
👉 which book we have to read next

#bookpodcast #bookishpodcast #podcasttrivia #podcastgameshow #booklovers #readingpodcast

Support the show

Editing done by Connor Luther @clfilms.co
Music by @thundercatlouis
Merch Here

We picked a “festive” thriller and plunge into a snowbound replica town where traps, cameras, and polite gatekeepers turn survival into a rigged game. We track the clues, debate the ethics, and wrestle with a final twist that flips victim and predator.

• star ratings split and initial expectations
• setup of Eddie’s abduction and the vintage town
• forming the group and spotting surveillance
• church shelter, booby-trapped “comforts,” and Tank’s death
• perimeter search, bear attack, and rising stakes
• bunker discovery, hunt archives, and the access tunnel
• carousel set piece and the predator’s fate
• hardware store explosion and trauma bond
• dawn meeting with the gatekeepers and twist reveal
• adaptation fancast and closing reflections

Like, share, subscribe, comment, follow, all the things

#BookReview
#BookTube
#ThrillerBooks
#PsychologicalThriller
#BetterWatchOut
#JamesSMurray
#Murr
#ImpracticalJokers
#CelebrityAuthor
#SuspenseReads
#TwistyThriller
#BookishYouTube
#WhenGirlsTalkBooks
#HonestReview

Support the show

Editing done by Connor Luther @clfilms.co
Music by @thundercatlouis
Merch Here

We sit down with Jessica Everly to explore Roses in Rome, a tender, emotionally intelligent romance where grief, forgiveness, and agency shape a love story rooted in place. Rome becomes a mirror for healing as Joey and Sienna choose each other without cheap drama or shortcuts.

• choosing Rome as a living catalyst for Sienna’s healing
• why Joey is a steady, emotionally present hero
• alternative endings cut in development
• crafting Father Fiore as a true spiritual guide
• Giuseppe as the road not taken
• hospital and Pietà scenes as grief touchstones
• adoption and pregnancy as a full family arc
• the sister dynamic and learning to show up
• querying rejections and the self‑publishing pivot
• cover design choices and author process
• what Jessica is writing next

Make sure to like, subscribe, share, follow. And also do the same for Jessica here so you can keep track on what she's gonna work on next

Support the show

Editing done by Connor Luther @clfilms.co
Music by @thundercatlouis
Merch Here

A single bouquet sets off a chain of goosebumps. We dive into Roses in Rome by Jessica Everly, a clean romance that starts with coffee drops in a Chicago law office and ends with a hard-won happily ever after braided through grief, family lore, and the art of choosing each other again. We follow Sienna—shell-shocked by a career setback and a devastating miscarriage—as she flies to Rome with her mom, stumbles into a priest who sketches between Mass and metaphors, and slowly reclaims her voice with a pencil, a plaza, and a mystery: why did the family’s flower order jump from eleven roses to twelve?

We rewind the Chicago timeline that made us swoon: a desk coffee courtship, a street festival first dance, a museum date that blooms into a rose garden proposal. Then we sit with what comes next: shattered routines, resentment born from different grief clocks, and work as a refuge that becomes a wall. In Rome, the legend of florist Lorenzo and a string of annual bouquets leads to Dona’s journals and a truth that reframes everything—love can survive repeated loss when it’s marked, remembered, and shared. No love triangle bait here; Giuseppe is a mirror, not a detour, and the Vatican scenes remind us that art can hold what words can’t.

The Florida chapter is where courage shows up. Sienna knocks on Joey’s door to apologize, and what could have been melodrama turns into something braver: two people naming what hurt, what was missed, and what they still want. On a quiet boat ride, forgiveness lands. The epilogue pays it forward with adoption, a surprise pregnancy, and a bouquet that grows to thirteen roses—a living ledger of love, loss, and legacy. If you’re searching for second-chance romance, clean storytelling, healing after miscarriage, and a touch of travel and art, this one will leave you teary, hopeful, and texting a friend.

Listen now, rate five stars if you cried even once, and share your favorite clean romance that made you believe in second chances. Subscribe for more thoughtful book chats and fan casts that might just predict the next big adaptation.

Support the show

Editing done by Connor Luther @clfilms.co
Music by @thundercatlouis
Merch Here

We talk with author Heather Coley about The Gilded Butterfly Effect, tracing how glamour, power, and campus mental health collide through the entwined voices of Stella and Penny. The conversation moves from craft to consequence, ending on the sharp note of a fate that feels earned and haunting.

• debut novel context and linked short stories
• crafting Stella’s voice and rapid interiority
• dual protagonists merging by design
• psychiatry, self-medication, and system failures
• writing drug scenes without glamorizing harm
• cyclical relapse risk and ambiguous endings
• blackout structure and tonal balance with humor
• moral ambiguity in romance and the Jack reveal
• classic literature influences and unhinged heroines
• dedication to dad, rejection, and persistence
• lessons for students about status and myth
• upcoming collection Public Property and where to follow Heather

Make sure to like, subscribe, share, follow
Go and get The Gilded Butterfly. It is out on October 21st
Watch our full length episode if you haven’t yet

Support the show

Editing done by Connor Luther @clfilms.co
Music by @thundercatlouis
Merch Here

A glittering sorority house. A basement ritual. Two girls trying to survive the performance. We dive into Heather Cawley’s Gilded Butterfly Effect with clear eyes and a full breakdown of why this debut hits like a bruise: parties that feel like auditions, therapy that feels like a pharmacy, and friendships that flare hot in a world built to look away.

We start with Stella, the curated “it” girl who micromanages pills and persona, and Penny, the outsider who wants to be seen so badly she mistakes attention for care. Their connection is electric and messy—equal parts comfort and misread—and it’s the fragile center of a story that asks how far you’ll go to feel safe in spaces designed for spectacle. Along the way we unpack the campus ecosystem: long counseling waitlists, parental posturing during football weekends, and the hush around hazing that reduces girls to proof. The pig roast isn’t just a plot device; it’s a map of power, consent, and the kind of loyalty that turns people into collateral.

Jack and Tripp anchor the spectrum of harm—the “nice” pledge with a soft voice and the golden boy who treats conquest as currency. We talk about complicity that hides in manners, why evidence disappears so easily, and how performative grief replaces accountability once the headlines fade. If you care about feminist fiction, campus novels, and the mechanics of coercion, this conversation goes deep: body image, drug culture, projection in therapy, and the ethics of silence when warning a friend might change everything.

We close with honest takeaways and a grounded 3.5 rating: not for shock value, but for the way this book names what too many institutions still stage-manage. If the episode resonates, tap follow, share it with a friend who loves sharp literary talk, and leave a quick review—what scene did you find hardest to forgive?

Support the show

Editing done by Connor Luther @clfilms.co
Music by @thundercatlouis
Merch Here

Two readers share summer standouts—Grave Matter and the polarizing, unforgettable Still Beating—then build a desert island library that mixes epic fantasy, nostalgia, and pure fun. We weigh comfort against challenge and admit that sometimes the best survival tool is a giant series.
• mini-series intro and summer theme
• Grave Matter as standout emotional read
• Still Beating dark romance premise and ethical tension
• island rules: no phones, no limits, long stay
• Zodiac Academy for length and escapism
• Yarros tearjerker and Twilight nostalgia
• Throne of Glass as new long series to try
• Manacled fanfic and Ice Planet Barbarians for volume
• library trading, survival book joke, playful wrap
Like, subscribe, share, follow

Support the show

Editing done by Connor Luther @clfilms.co
Music by @thundercatlouis
Merch Here

What would you sacrifice to bring back someone you've lost? How far would you go to preserve a love that defies death itself? These are the questions at the heart of Corina Halley's mesmerizing psychological thriller, "Grave Matter."

When Sydney arrives at the remote Madrona Foundation on Vancouver Island, she's eager to participate in groundbreaking scientific research that could revolutionize treatments for neurological conditions like the Alzheimer's that took her grandmother. The isolation doesn't bother her – she's focused on the work and the opportunity to prove herself after losing her Stanford scholarship. But from the moment her fellow passenger Amani mysteriously vanishes upon arrival, Sydney senses something deeply wrong with the foundation.

The cult-like atmosphere becomes increasingly unsettling – surrendered phones, ironclad NDAs, and a disturbing mantra: "Don't try to change the lodge, let the lodge change you." When Sydney encounters Professor Wes Kincaid, the brooding lead researcher who also serves as the mandatory psychologist for all participants, their immediate attraction creates a dangerous complication. Their relationship evolves from tense therapy sessions to forbidden romance, all while Sydney experiences increasingly terrifying phenomena – visions of a girl hanging from a tree, a half-rotted wolf with a still-beating heart covered in fungus, and the persistent feeling that her reality keeps glitching.

The truth, when it finally emerges, is more horrifying than Sydney could have imagined. The Madrona Foundation's experiments with the mysterious "excandesco amanita" fungus aren't just about curing disease – they're about conquering death itself. And Sydney isn't experiencing these events for the first time; she died on the island and was brought back, her memories reset multiple times as part of an ongoing experiment orchestrated by the foundation's ruthless leaders.

As Sydney pieces together her fragmented reality and fights to expose the truth, she must decide if the love she's found with Wes is worth the terrible price they've both paid. Can something beautiful grow from such darkness? And when you've been rewritten by science that defies nature, can you ever truly trust yourself again?

Dive into this haunting tale of science gone wrong, the lingering power of memory, and a love that refuses to die. Your perception of reality will never be the same.

Support the show

Editing done by Connor Luther @clfilms.co
Music by @thundercatlouis
Merch Here