• Ep. 88 - Nepal, Biggie F, and The Old Man Of The Lake
    Jan 13 2026

    This place has everything...hauntings, disappearances, cryptids, U.F.O.s....everything! Tune in to this month's episode to hear all about Crater Lake. Also Marlene trips us out with time travel talk :)


    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Mostra di più Mostra meno
    58 min
  • Ep. 87 - A Ghostie Started The Fire
    Dec 13 2025

    HAPPY HOLIDAYS!


    For our holiday episode what better way to celebrate than to talk about ghost fires! This month Alyssa covers the Fire Spook of Caledonia Mills. We also share our experiences from investigating the Bell Witch Cave!


    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Mostra di più Mostra meno
    1 ora e 32 min
  • Ep. 86 - The Case of Dr. John Schneeberger
    Nov 13 2025

    On Halloween night, 1992 a woman named Candice was seen by her doctor, John Schneeberger. Little did she know he wasn't as trustworthy as she thought...


    *trigger warning of sexual assault for this episode


    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Mostra di più Mostra meno
    1 ora e 4 min
  • Ep. 85 - The Anniversary Special
    Oct 13 2025

    It's Marlene & Alyssa's 1 year anniversary and to celebrate we have some very fitting paranormal stories for you. Also, since it's been a whole month...Marlene's Not So Fun Fun Fact kind of turned into some Not So Fun Fun News talking about some upsetting current events. Answer in this week's poll if you're into that idea!


    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Mostra di più Mostra meno
    1 ora e 17 min
  • Ep. 84 - Season Two Premiere...THE DILLYMARN
    Sep 13 2025

    WELCOME BACK! Marlene and Alyssa are back with the first episode of season two and folks, it's a good one. We've got cyrptids, we've got Conjuring House updates, we've got sound effects! Don't be lame, give it a listen and tell your friends. Oh and stay spooky!


    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Mostra di più Mostra meno
    35 min
  • Ep. 83 - Moll Dyer
    Aug 13 2025

    Unmarried, elderly, AND Catholic??? Witch, for sure. This week Alyssa talks about a possible (but probably not) witch named Moll Dyer & Marlene talks about an impending tsunami!


    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Mostra di più Mostra meno
    34 min
  • Ep. 82 - The Chest of Death
    Aug 6 2025

    Every family has that heirloom that gets passed down through generations, but most of these heirlooms don't kill the family members in the process...



    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Mostra di più Mostra meno
    1 ora
  • Ep. 81 - Danny Phantom
    Jul 30 2025

    Danny the poltergeist is pretty cool...as long as you don't sleep in his bed!



    This podcast is all about the stories you want to hear, so please send in any suggestions of stories you want us to cover to whatsyourfavoritescarystory@gmail.com. We want to cover everything spooky...the paranormal, aliens, urban legends, cryptids, true crime, etc. So don't be shy and send us your ideas!

    Mostra di più Mostra meno
    28 min