The Dreadful Double
Impossibile aggiungere al carrello
Rimozione dalla Lista desideri non riuscita.
Non è stato possibile aggiungere il titolo alla Libreria
Non è stato possibile seguire il Podcast
Esecuzione del comando Non seguire più non riuscita
-
Letto da:
-
Di:
Opening poem: “I Went to the Movies Hoping Just Once the Monster Got the Girl” by Ron Koertge
Read it here (though the website messed up the title).
##
Main segment: Kel flails around a little trying to summarize this unreliably narrated story of memory and delusion. Deke focuses on the protean nature of identity, name dropping some dope philosophers. Daniels unpacks the story like a detective hot on the case, trying to solve the same mystery the protagonist is after: Who is Andy O’Day?
You can find Dan Chaon’s story in the collection Among the Missing, in its original form in the Gettysburg Review, or you can read it here.
##
SOLUTION TO LAST EPISODE’S LOGIC PUZZLE:
My answer: If A is a knave, then A just said something true. But knaves cannot say true things. So A is not a knave. So A is a knight. But if A is a knight and spoke truthfully, then B must be a knave. So A is a knight and B is a knave.
Smullyan’s answer: (28) Suppose A were knave. Then the statement “At least one of us is a knave” would be false (since knaves make false statements); hence they would both be knights. Thus, if A were a knave he would also have to be a knight, which is impossible. Therefore A is not a knave; he is a knight. Therefore his statement must be true, so at least one of them really is a knave. Since A is a knight, then B must be the knave. So A is a knight and B is a knave.
THIS EPISODE’S PUZZLE:
(29) Suppose A says, “Either I am a knave or B is a knight.” What are A and B?
[answer to follow next time, along with a new puzzle…]
This is a public episode. If you would like to discuss this with other subscribers or get access to bonus episodes, visit keldaniels.substack.com