Champions League football is secured, Old Trafford is bouncing again, and the mood around the club has completely shifted. But the biggest decision of the INEOS era is just days away: Is Michael Carrick the permanent answer?

In this special deep-dive episode of Devils in the Box, Joe weighs up the pros and cons of handing the keys to the club legend. Since replacing Ruben Amorim in January 2026, Carrick has achieved the "impossible," taking a side drifting in 7th to a guaranteed Champions League spot with three games to spare. With a staggering record of 10 wins and 2 draws from his 14 league games, the stats are undeniable—but is he the man for the long-term project?

We analyse the tactical maturity Carrick has shown, moving away from a back three to a fluid 4-2-3-1 that has revitalized the likes of Casemiro and Bruno Fernandes. We also discuss the overwhelming support from the dressing room, with Kobbie Mainoo and Matheus Cunha publicly stating they would "die for him" on the pitch.

However, we don't shy away from the tough questions. We tackle the "Lack of Experience"—argument many of pundits have expressed—and ask if he can sustain this momentum over a grueling 38-game title charge. Plus, with Bournemouth’s Andoni Iraola reportedly being monitored by the board, are United at risk of passing up a tactical "innovator" for a "club man"?

Get Involved:

Check out the Q&A feature below: Carrick or Iraola? Has Michael Carrick done enough to earn a three-year deal, or do you still want a "big name" in the dugout for the Champions League?

🔴 About Devils in the Box:

Hosted by Joe—a former amateur journalist whose impact on the world of Man Utd reporting was roughly as significant as Antony's right foot. Expect honest, banter-heavy, and fiercely optimistic takes on all things Manchester United as we finally start to believe again.

🔔 SUBSCRIBE, FOLLOW & RATE!

Whether you're watching on YouTube or listening on Spotify and Apple Podcasts, make sure to hit that follow/subscribe button and leave us a 5-star rating to help push the pod! Up the Reds!

#ManUtd #MUFC #MichaelCarrick #INEOS #PremierLeague #ChampionsLeague #AndoniIraola #ManUtdNews #OldTrafford #SirJimRatcliffe