Greg and Nathan are back for Week 3 with a fun theme: Great Idea, Bad Movie. Once again, they’re joined by special guest Nathan Bartlebaugh to break down films that looked like guaranteed hits on paper, but somehow missed the mark.

They kick things off by comparing the original premise to the final product, asking the big question: how do you fumble something that seemed so promising? From there, they dig into exactly where things went sideways, whether it’s messy writing, inconsistent tone, sideways expectation, or pacing that just couldn’t keep up.

To keep things fair, they wrap up by highlighting at least one thing each film actually got right, because even flawed movies usually have a spark of something good.

If you’ve ever walked out of a movie thinking “this should’ve been amazing,” this episode is for you.

Some movies fade as soon as the credits roll, but others linger, echoing in your mind days, weeks, even years later. In this episode, Greg and Nathan are joined by returning guest Nathan Bartlebaugh to dive into the films they just can’t shake.

Each host brings movies that have stayed with them long after the first watch, unpacking what gives these stories their lasting power. Is it an unforgettable character? A haunting ending? A theme that hits a little too close to home? Along the way, they each highlight one scene from their picks that refuses to let go.

But this isn’t just about great movies, it’s about great storytelling. The conversation turns toward what writers can learn from these films and how to craft stories that truly stick with an audience.

Greg and Nathan kick off a new series with a deep dive into the 2026 Oscars, joined by special guest Nathan Bartlebaugh. In this Week 1 episode, the trio breaks down Hollywood’s biggest night, unpacking what the Academy got right… and where it may have missed the mark.

From the night’s biggest winners to the most debated decisions, they ask the big question: were the top honors truly deserved? They spotlight the year’s most surprising snubs and overlooked performances, and what those omissions might reveal about the industry’s current direction.

Plus, Greg, Nathan, and Nathan each share their personal picks, who should have taken home the gold, and reflect on what this year’s Oscars say about the evolving tastes and priorities of Hollywood.

Whether you’re an awards junkie or just love great movies, this episode delivers sharp takes, lively debate, and plenty of film fan insight.