Send us Fan Mail

Eva and Caroline go all in on American politics this week — a full hour tracing how the Democratic and Republican parties got to where they are today, from the Clinton and Reagan eras through to now. They get personal about their own political journeys, including a confession about a 2016 vote that wasn't exactly popular among friends at the time, and what actually changed after October 7th. The conversation moves through antisemitism and why it's a warning sign worth everyone's attention, the "surplus elite" theory of why so many overeducated, high-achieving people are drawn toward the far left, the role social media plays in deepening our echo chambers, and a candid, personal take on losing friendships over who voted for whom.

In this episode:

• The Democratic Party's shift from Clinton-era centrism to today's progressive wing
• The Republican Party's shift from Reagan-era conservatism to Trump-era populism
• Our own political journeys, and what changed our minds along the way
• Why antisemitism matters as a bellwether for everyone, not just Jewish people
• The "surplus elite" theory and why it's resonating right now
• How social media echo chambers are reshaping how people vote
• A real conversation about losing friends over politics
• What each party actually stands for today, broken down plainly
• Why voting locally matters more than people think

CHAPTERS

0:00 — Welcome
2:16 — Why America Still Matters
5:48 — The Democrats: The Clinton Era
8:29 — Obama, Immigration, and the ACA
17:36 — The Left's Shift: Bernie, the Squad, and Media Reactions
22:17 — 2016, Trump, and Learning to Listen
23:25 — The Republicans: Reagan to Trump
29:02 — Trump's Character, COVID Media, and October 7th
31:54 — Media Trust, Hillary, and Biden's Decline
38:17 — Antisemitism, Social Media, and Radicalization
40:43 — What Each Party Actually Stands For
44:10 — Closing Thoughts and Call to Vote
44:51 — Mic Drop

Resources mentioned:

• Vote.org — register to vote and find your polling place
• Ballotpedia — research local candidates and races

We’re two New York City women talking candidly about the chaos of modern life, from relationships, parenting, working in and out of the home, to what it takes to stay semi-sane in a world that expects you to hold it all together and be #blessed.

We couldn’t find an honest and vulnerable conversation — so we started one! If you need a laugh, a cry, or just want to hear someone else admit their flaws and validate your crazy, you’re in the right place. Be ready to be… Unfiltered, Unafraid, and UnExpert.

Please follow, like, review, and share the podcast with your family and friends!

• Follow us on Instagram https://www.instagram.com/micdandmedicated and YouTube https://www.youtube.com/@MicdMedicated/podcasts
• Subscribe to our Substack: https://substack.com/@micdandmedicated
• Check out our website: micdandmedicated.com

Surgeon General Warning Disclaimer: We are self-prescribed unexperts, so if you have any real questions or need real advice, please call your nearest doctor.

© 2025 Eva Heyman & Caroline Leventhal