In this episode, Jason König and Jonathan Westaway interview Lachlan Fleetwood about his research on Himalayan history.
Lachlan is a historian of science, empire, geography and environment. He completed his PhD in History at the University of Cambridge in 2020, and has subsequently held research fellowships at University College Dublin, Yale and Munich. His first book, Science on the Roof of the World: Empire and the Remaking of the Himalaya, was published by Cambridge University Press in May 2022. The book examines ‘exploration and imperial knowledge production in the Himalaya during a period when scientific practices evolved alongside the realization of the true scale of the mountains’ heights’, with a special focus on the interplay between science and empire.
Lachlan sketches out for us some of his fascination with early 19th-century Himalayan history. This was a period when new ideas about altitude were developing very rapidly. The podcast explores changing patterns of Western interaction with local populations, culminating in the final confirmation of Everest as the highest mountain the world in 1856, and the end of East India Company rule in the Indian subcontinent in 1857. Just 50 years before, Western scientists had believed that Chimborazo in Ecuador was the highest mountain in the world, and claims about the height of the mountains of the Himalaya had been widely doubted. We examine the emergence of the idea of measuring and comparing a mountain’s altitude as a way of knowing mountains. This was a Western scientific approach that replaced other cultural approaches to high places and overwrote indigenous ways of understanding mountain spaces. So this is a story about when and why we decided that altitude above sea level is something that should make some mountains matter more than others.
We discuss some of the challenges and frustrations involved in doing science in the mountains in this period, for example through malfunctioning or poorly designed equipment. Lachlan also talks us through some of the many first-person accounts of the difficulties involved in surveying or collecting geological specimens in border regions, for example on the border with Tibet, where there was a constant risk of conflict with Qing border officials. We also discuss the importance of indigenous brokers and intermediaries in the production of scientific knowledge, and the relationship between western and indigenous conceptions of mountain landscapes.
Finally, Lachlan looks ahead to some exciting new possibilities, including a future project on notions of habitability and uninhabitability in 19th-century Asia. He also reflects on the way in which studying the long history of mountains can help us to see that many of our current ways of thinking about geographical space are not as inevitable as they appear. Looking to the past, to understand how our ideas about mountains developed, can help us to question some of the things we take for granted in our approach to mountains, and perhaps open up space to think about our engagement with mountain environments differently in the future.
This episode was edited by Zofia Guertin.
You can follow the project on Bluesky @futuremountain.bsky.social
To learn more about the Mountain Stories, Mountain Futures project please visit our website here (https://msmf.wp.st-andrews.ac.uk)