Send us Fan Mail

How the Medicare Modernization Act Fueled Medicare Advantage Overpayments and Rebates

Mike Roth and Bill Kadereit discuss how the 2003 Medicare Modernization Act (MMA), following the failure of Medicare Choice, rebranded the program as Medicare Advantage and used risk adjustments and subsidies that raised MA payments above traditional fee-for-service, averaging about 14% higher from 2005–2009. They cite Inspector General reports in 2008–2009 criticizing excessive and improper payments, which they say were later recast as “rebates” under the 2010 Affordable Care Act, driving overpayments to roughly 16–17% and persisting through projected 2025 levels. They report MA enrollment growth (11.7M to 17.5M from 2010–2015; 34.4M and 55% market share by 2025) and rebate totals (about $89B in 2025, projected over $94B), arguing rebates subsidize extra benefits and insurer overhead/profit while traditional Medicare enrollees receive none, and urging policymakers to end rebates while protecting current beneficiaries.

Chapters
00:00 Podcast Introduction
00:57 MMA And Medicare Advantage
03:37 Risk Adjustment Explained
05:18 Overpayments And Rebates
07:18 Charts Show Rising Costs
09:31 Enrollment Growth And Market Share
10:39 Rebates Fund Extra Perks
12:43 Trillion Dollar Forecast
14:51 Fairness And Reform Ideas
15:59 Next Episode Preview