Episode 2: a cold-case closure fifty-two years in the making opens the show, then four deep rewinds — Villisca, Susan Smith, Faith Hedgepeth, and the Matthew Perry prosecutions — plus quick hits, the watch corner with the Alexander brothers sentencing, and the Halloween weekend teasers.

Segments:

0:00 — Theme

0:11 — Welcome + how this show works

1:31 — Melissa Ann Smith: DNA closure in Utah

3:48 — Villisca Axe Murders (1912, still unsolved)

7:35 — Susan Smith (parole hearing November 19, 2026)

11:12 — Faith Hedgepeth (verdict October 23, 2026)

15:12 — Matthew Perry prosecutions

18:58 — Quick hits: Rebecca Scofield · Kirby Carpenter · A.J. Armstrong update

25:24 — Watch corner: Alexander brothers sentencing · The Serial Killer Connection finale · The Pet Cemetery Murders finale · Friday Watch · Sistas Who Kill listening note

32:01 — Close: Annabelle teaser · Martha Moxley (October 30) · Ronald Clark O'Bryan (October 31)

32:45 — Names roll

33:35 — Question of the week

34:02 — Sign-off

Hosted by Mrs Rewind the Crime. Follow the channel: @mrsrewindthecrime on TikTok and Instagram.