The Dallas Stars are finding ways to win—but are they fixing their biggest weakness?

Ryan, Chris, and James debate what the Colorado Avalanche home-and-home split and Chicago Blackhawks shutout actually tell us about this team. Jake Oettinger is delivering outstanding goaltending, Casey DeSmith keeps Dallas competitive, and Arttu Hyry is making a case for more opportunity. But inconsistent offense still leaves plenty to question.

The David Perron signing sparks a bigger argument: Are the Stars adding needed scoring depth, or could their preference for veterans squeeze out a younger player who has earned his spot?

Plus: Roope Hintz’s physical play and health, Tyler Seguin’s production, Miro Heiskanen’s impact, competing predictions for Jason Robertson’s next contract, and expectations for a six-game homestand.

Episode 8-011 | October 18, 2026

We’re Looking for Sponsors!

If you or your business want to partner with a passionate, growing hockey podcast with a loyal Dallas Stars fanbase, we’d love to connect. Check out our media kit by clicking here to learn how you can support Starcastic Remarks and reach a dedicated NHL audience.

JOIN THE Who CARES Club!

Love Starcastic Remarks? Join our membership club, The Who Cares Club! For $5/month, you get some exclusive perks and help the most sarcastic Stars podcast continue to grow and continue on! Click here to join!

Help us grow by leaving a 5-star review wherever you listen to podcasts—it makes a huge difference! Watch us on YouTube and click like & subscribe and hit that notification bell! Follow us across social media for updates, highlights, and behind-the-scenes content:

• YouTube: @StarcasticR
• Twitter (X): @StarcasticR
• Discord: Join Here
• TikTok: @StarcasticR
• Instagram: @StarcasticR
• Facebook: @StarcasticR

Visit our website here for more content!

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.