Part 1 laid bare what happens when well-meaning practices ask too much, too soon, without the systems to support it.

In this second conversation, we deliberately turn the lens the other way.

I’m joined by Dr. Moriah McCauley, a veterinarian now five years into practice, who shares what it looks like when graduate support is done well – thoughtfully, deliberately, and humanely.

Moriah’s story matters because it shows what’s possible. She’s still in the same practice five years on, not through resilience alone, but because the system around her was built for success from day one.

Together we talk about what attracted her to the role in the first place, how expectations were clarified early, and why mentorship is not a single person or a buzzword, but a culture. One that includes planned progression, real availability, psychological safety, and permission to be human when life gets complicated.

This episode explores the practical reality of guiding – not grinding – graduates. What it requires from leaders. What it asks of graduates. And why, done properly, it creates loyalty, competence, confidence, and long-term value for everyone involved.

This conversation forms the second half of a two-part series and sits alongside the session I’ll be delivering at VMX 2026: Guiding, Not Grinding.

Episode Outline:

[00:01] – Why this conversation matters

[02:00] – Meet Dr. Moriah

[04:30] – Choosing a first practice

[07:00] – Spotting a culture of mentorship

[09:30] – Gut instinct and psychological safety

[12:00] – Setting expectations early

[15:00] – What good mentorship looks like

[17:30] – Being supported through hard moments

[21:00] – The cost of investing in graduates

[24:30] – Return on investment, done properly

[27:00] – Learning the hardest skill: communication

[30:30] – Why Moriah stayed

[32:30] – What leaders need to hear next

Follow Dr Dave Nicol:

Instagram: @drdavenicol

Learn more about leadership support and training: Veterinary Leadership Academy

See more from Dr. Moriah McCauley: https://www.instagram.com/dr.moriah.mccauley

Connect with Dr. Moriah McCauley: https://www.linkedin.com/in/moriah-mccauley

Enjoyed the episode?

Please leave a review on Apple Podcasts or Spotify. These conversations matter, and sharing them helps move our profession forward.