In the Appalachian Mountains of southwest Virginia, there are some stories that linger long after the music stops.

This first episode of Roots & Shadows: The Real Appalachia begins with one of them.

In the early 1970s, a young woman attended a community dance in Smyth County — a familiar Saturday-night ritual where families gathered, teenagers laughed, and trust in the town still felt intact. By the end of the night, she never made it home.

What followed was a murder investigation, a trial, and the conviction of a local man: Lem Tuggle Jr.

But this story does not begin in a courtroom.

It begins in the quiet spaces that came afterward — in families who stopped talking, in names that were avoided, and in a community that learned how to carry grief without ever fully addressing it.

Told from a personal, firsthand perspective, this episode explores the case of Lem Tuggle Jr. not to sensationalize violence, but to examine what happens when crime collides with family, place, and generational silence. It is a story about accountability, memory, and the long shadows cast by a single night in a close-knit Appalachian community.

Some details have been handled with care out of respect for those affected, but the events themselves are real — and their impact is still felt.

This is not just a true-crime story.

It is a story about roots, and the shadows they sometimes hide.

Where every root tells a story, and every shadow hides one.

Roots & Shadows: The Real Appalachia is a narrative podcast exploring true stories from the Appalachian Mountains, stories shaped by place, family, and the things people stop talking about.

Drawn from public court records, historical reporting, and word of mouth passed through generations, each episode examines how violence, silence, faith, and memory take root in small communities and how their shadows linger long after.

Some names have been changed, and certain details are dramatized for storytelling. What remains is the truth of what happened, and the lives forever changed by it.

Where every root tells a story, and every shadow hides one.