In this fifth installment of Tales from the Archives, we uncover three haunting, unfinished stories pulled straight from early 20th-century newspapers — stories where Italian immigrants were remembered in headlines, but forgotten in history.

We begin in 1911 Southern Colorado, where an Italian rancher is found murdered on a lonely county road near Aguilar. A former business partner is arrested, a posse is formed, and newspapers eagerly report the violence — but the story abruptly disappears, leaving unanswered questions about justice and what became of those involved.

Next, we turn to a national scandal involving the son of President William Howard Taft. After a tragic automobile accident in Massachusetts leaves an Italian laborer with a fractured skull, newspapers focus almost entirely on the president’s distress and his son’s remorse — while the injured immigrant himself fades into the background. His name appears misspelled, his identity obscured, and his fate ultimately unknown.

Finally, we travel to Pueblo’s Italian community in 1925, where a groom vanishes just days before his long-awaited church wedding. Accusations of kidnapping, jealousy, poisoning, and scandal swirl through the press, but conflicting reports and misspelled names make it impossible to determine what truly happened — or whether the groom disappeared by force or by choice.

These are stories of violence, love, jealousy, power, and erasure, told through the imperfect lens of old newspapers. Tales from the Archives explores not just what was reported — but what was left out.

If you’re drawn to historical true crime, Italian American history, forgotten headlines, and mysteries lost to time, this episode is for you.