Get ready for a whole lotta cookies! Before we launch into season 2 of Caroline in the City, we take a flying leap into the dusty wilderness of the interwebs to explore the Caroline fandom, past and present! Warm up the flux capacitor and journey back to the future with us to a world of cease and desist letters, arbitrary femslash, Weep Cutes, undercover strippers, and an expensive eBay item that besmirches the good names of all our heroes. Yer a wizard, Richard!

Could it be… Satan? We officially bid farewell to Season One with the infamous "hot dog show", episode 1.24, "Caroline and the Condom"! Flash back with us and hear our theories about the baffling clip show of highlights that never were: the relative jankiness of the Rum Tum Tugger, businessmen through pandemic goggles, correct amounts of muffin, pierced hats, and the magnificent glutes of Lutes. Save room for "dessert"!

It's an omen! It's cliffhanger time in The City as wedding bells of doom start to ring in episode 1.23, "Caroline and the Wedding"! Don your best ren faire garb and crack open a bottle of Chianti as we attempt to answer the important questions: Will "sincere amore" win the day? Will Father Damian get a spin-off? Will Del's cousins arrive from San Francisco? Is a hot dog dessert? Did Richard pay for his breadsticks? Are we making it all up? Awooooo!!!