In this chilling episode of Burden of Proof: True Crime Uncovered, host Chris Burden takes listeners to Mount Vernon, Ohio, where one of the most bizarre and horrifying cases in recent history unfolded. In November 2010, a quiet small town was rocked by the disappearance of Tina Herrmann, her children Sarah and Kody, and family friend Stephanie Sprang. What began as a missing persons case soon revealed a nightmare that defied explanation.

Investigators uncovered a crime scene soaked in blood, dismembered remains hidden inside a hollowed tree, and a lone survivor — 13-year-old Sarah Maynard, rescued from the home of a man consumed by a disturbing obsession with leaves. That man was Matthew Hoffman.

Through survivor accounts, forensic evidence, and the relentless pursuit of law enforcement, this episode unravels Hoffman’s twisted crimes, the resilience of young Sarah, and the lasting scars left on the community of Mount Vernon.

In this episode, you’ll hear:

• The story of Tina Herrmann, her children Sarah and Kody, and Stephanie Sprang
• How investigators uncovered one of the most gruesome crime scenes in Ohio history
• The bizarre details of Matthew Hoffman’s obsession with trees and leaves
• Sarah Maynard’s survival and rescue after four days of captivity
• The community’s grief, resilience, and search for healing

Learn more about my work in investigations and security at burdenofproof.llc. 📘 And check out my book Burden of the Badge to read more about my journey in law enforcement and private investigation.

Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and share Burden of Proof: True Crime Uncovered to help us continue shining a light on cases that matter.

In this episode of Burden of Proof: True Crime Uncovered, host Chris Burden revisits one of Ohio’s most heartbreaking and controversial cases — the 1982 murders of Annette Cooper and Todd Schultz.

What began as the story of two young lovers full of promise turned into a community’s worst nightmare. Their brutal killings shocked Logan, Ohio, and sparked an investigation that quickly unraveled into one of the state’s most infamous wrongful convictions. For years, Dale Johnston sat on death row for a crime he did not commit, while the true killers walked free.

Through twists of injustice, advancements in forensic science, and the persistence of investigators, the truth finally came to light. This episode explores the devastating impact of a flawed system, the resilience of families seeking answers, and the long-delayed justice that eventually revealed the real perpetrators.

What you’ll hear in this episode:

• The tragic disappearance and discovery of Annette and Todd
• How a wrongful conviction shattered lives and divided a community
• The flaws in the justice system that put an innocent man on death row
• The forensic breakthroughs that finally solved the case
• Reflections on resilience, accountability, and justice delayed

If you’d like to learn more about my work in investigations and security, visit burdenofproof.llc. And check out my book Burden of the Badge to read more about my journey in law enforcement and private investigation.

Don’t forget to subscribe, rate, and share Burden of Proof: True Crime Uncovered so we can continue shining a light on the cases that matter.

In this gripping episode of Burden of Proof: True Crime Uncovered, host Chris Burden takes listeners deep into one of Ohio’s most haunting cold cases — the 1983 murder of 15-year-old John “Tony” Muncy. What began as a routine night out for a shy, kindhearted teenager quickly spiraled into a decades-long mystery that baffled investigators and devastated a family.

From the shocking discovery of Tony’s dismembered body in rural Delaware County to the painstaking investigation that stalled for years, this episode unravels the twists, dead ends, and chilling suspects who came under scrutiny. Listeners will hear how law enforcement refused to give up, revisiting the case decades later with groundbreaking DNA technology that finally identified the killer, bringing long-awaited closure to Tony’s family and community.

This is not just a story of tragedy — it’s a testament to resilience, the evolution of forensic science, and the relentless pursuit of justice.