After the final whistle blew on Halloween afternoon, NYCFC already knew their fate. Their playoff hopes hinged upon them being able to secure all three points at home against the worst team in the Eastern Conference. With all of that pressure on the line the team folded in stoppage time conceding an equalizer.

Luckily for our faithful listeners we brought on the spirited voice of Jessica Charman from Apple TV to share her story and journey with us and to give us her insight into what was a very difficult season for the club.

What else could go wrong for NYCFC in 2026? Losing your starting goal keeper in the 28th minute of a must-win game, check. Having a penalty kick goal disallowed because the shooter did not wait for the whistle, check. The list continues to grow as this team under Pascal Jansen continues to drop points in creative ways. Ultimately the game cannot be considered a complete failure as they would salvage a draw with the final kick of the match, but still feels disappointing considering the season as a whole.

This week Mike Anderer, Mike Allen and J.R. diBart continue the conversation about the ambitions of Brad Sims for NYCFC to be the flagship club for MLS. All three of the hosts agree that the team has a way to go before achieving that realistic and attainable goal (Sim's words, not the author's).

With few points left to spare this season NYCFC only earned one point out of a possible six, but strangely the mood around the team feels lighter than in weeks past. The midweek opponent was one of the Eastern Conference's toughest and the visitor's on Saturday despite being out of the top four in the west brought a dominant attacking threat. And NYCFC held their own against the likes of Son and Bouanga to salvage the point and hopefully build towards a road victory this coming Saturday in Orlando.

This week Mike Anderer, Mike Allen and J.R. diBart go into a deep dive on Etihad Park after Mike Allen got to tour the venue in the final stages of its construction. Then the trio talk about the two matches from the week and look ahead at the bleak but still attainable playoff picture for the club.

This is definitely in the top 5 of worst NYCFC losses and it comes at the worst time. NYCFC continues to skid down the table. They've been woeful in the last 11 games and the competition for the next three matches does not get any easier.

This week the guys try and hold it together as they discuss the biggest question facing the club, "Do they believe in themselves?"

NYCFC need a mental break. The team is in its own head. Head Coach, Pascal Jansen, and midfielder, Johhny Shore, both shared those thoughts after the 2-2 draw from Atlanta. Luckily for the players and the coaching staff alike, MLS is off for international break and this might just be the pause that the team needs to get their mojo back and be competitive for the remaining eight games of the season.

This week Mike Anderer, Mike Allen and J.R. diBart share their views on what can help improve the mood and the results for the team.

The season started with so much hope and promise. A full preseason with Jansen, a stable roster, and the anticipation of new additions. Then the injuries happened. Then the dropped points started to add up. Then the realization hit that this could be one of the worst point totals in NYCFC history.

Then to add insult to injury, the club signs former Red Bull defender Matt Miazga.

This week Mike Anderer, Mike Allen, and J.R. diBart share their thoughts on the game and what the addition of the former defender of the year means to season.

Streaks happen in sports. It is part of the cycle of a season. NYCFC can only hope that the victory on Saturday is a pivotal moment for the remainder of their season with only nine games remaining and the team clinging to a playoff position.

This week Mike Anderer, Mike Allen and J.R. diBart discuss the two matches from last week and share audio from Pascal Jansen, Assistant Coach, Medhi Ballouchy, and Thiago Martins.

The hottest team in MLS entered Yankee Stadium on a crisp late summer night and the hometown Boys In Blue humbled the visitors with a gritty 0-0 draw. It wasn't without drama and near misses, but it was good enough to keep NYCFC above the playoff line as the number of remaining games shrinks to eleven.

This week Christian Smith fills in for JR diBart as the guys talk about the scoreless match from Friday and share post-game audio clips from Matt Freese, Thiago Martins and Nico Fernandez Mercau.