Should you pay up for Tarik Skubal in the first round, or is loading up on hitters the smarter play? Joe Bond, AJ Applegarth, and Corey Pieper debate the pitching draft strategy that actually wins 2026 fantasy baseball leagues—and they don't all agree.

With pitcher IL days skyrocketing (15,000+ days missed in 2024) and starters averaging just 5.19 innings per outing, the old "pocket aces" strategy is getting flipped on its head. The guys hash out whether you need one elite arm or four mid-tier anchors, when it's too early to draft an ace (spoiler: Joe will never take one in the early first), and why Christopher Sanchez at SP6 makes Joe uncomfortable but Corey's all in.

Plus: Why chasing wins is a "fool's errand" (Brady Singer had more wins than Skubal—let that sink in), the closers worth paying up for (hint: it's a very short list), and why Grant Hollar might be this year's league-winning waiver add in saves+holds leagues.

Key Debates:

• Is Skubal worth a top-6 pick? (They disagree)
• Sanchez at SP6: Breakout or one-year mirage?
• Should you draft Jacob deGrom? (Hard pass from all three)
• Quality starts are dead—switch to quality appearances

Join Fantasy Six Pack for rankings, projections, and Discord access: fantasysixpack.net/plans (Code: F6PPODS saves 15%)

Hosted by Simplecast, an AdsWizz company. See pcm.adswizz.com for information about our collection and use of personal data for advertising.