Maybe not the right narrator

Look, it's like 60+ hours long of one narrator so I can only imagine I'd get sick of anyone's voice after that long. Keep that in mind for this review:

There are a few things that stand out as negatives: 1) Alan Munro's voice is so deep, it hurt my ears to listen to on my car stereo. I changed my EQ settings to a really extreme setting just to get it tolerable. Maybe with headphones it would have been better, IDK. It's the biggest negative in my book. 2) The audio editor added a tin-y effect things, only occasionally, when people in the story were in different rooms or far away. It was hard to hear and made for an awkward transition. A listener's willing suspension of disbelief would have sufficed. 3) The narrator has a stilted delivery, which I thought was intentional at first because of all the Russian names but the pace never got quicker, and it made the story harder to understand. 4) Sometimes it was like they spliced in a name after the fact because the original pronunciation was poor. This added to the stiltedness. Maybe a fluent Russian speaker would have been a better narrator?

As for the good things or neutral points: The plot is plodding, generally good but rarely exciting except a few parts. There are some parts that draw on unnecessarily in my opinion. There are parts where the author goes on at length, somewhat pedantically, on history, human nature, and society. I just don't think the length really helped make it better or clearer. There are some aspects that haven't aged as well for 2019 when I write this, primarily in the form of patriarchy, bording on misogyny at times, and maybe even overly sexualization of young women. Reading it in context of nearly 200 years ago, I guess it's something I can acknowledge and move past, but it didn't add to the book. I wonder how much is the translation as well.

The really good parts: I can say I finished a tome of a classic!

If you've got time to kill on a long car ride and nothing else tops your list or you want to check the box, do it, but maybe look for another narrator and consider if they are better or worse.

4 persone l'hanno trovata utile

War and Peace

I have set out to read W & P several times and got bogged down and never completed it. I am new to audiobook and thought I would let someone read it to me. Quite by accident I found this translation and the narration by Alan Munro. I find Mr Munro’s tone soothing and relaxing, just right for this long adventure. I thoroughly enjoyed the experience and recommend this to others who wish to tackle this great novel.

3 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Narrator is near impossible to listen to

The narrator voice will put you to sleep quickly. And the voice is so rich and low sounding, that if you’re listening in the car, it will be impossible to distinguish words from each other, and it just sounds very monotonous and boring. I made it through like 30 minutes of the 40 hours of audio. Get a different version with a different narrator

3 persone l'hanno trovata utile

A listening delight

Having read the book a long while back, this audio book was quite a delightful journey to the past for me. I enjoyed it tremendously. It lasted long & didn't want it to end.

2 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Voice acting is important

Maybe I've been spoiled by other audiobooks but the I found that the lack of voice acting with book made it difficult to follow the story. I've never had this problem before but then again I haven't listened to a ton of audiobooks. Here the narrator mostly doesn't shift his voice when moving from narration to quoting what a person says. I've gone and purchased another book, one with better reviews. If I'm going to take the time to read a book, I want it to be the best of the options available. Thankfully, there are plenty of options for an old classic like this.

1 persona l'ha trovata utile

Audio Skips

In book eleven, ch.18 the audio skips and restarts the chapter but then doesn’t actually finish it before skipping to the next one

Bad narrator

Every character is the same monotones never changes completely ruined book for me
Get different narrator

It’s long, but that’s a good thing.

War and Peace is funny, moving and engaging. The characters are nuanced and imperfect, which makes the story much more interesting.

Tolstoy’s exploration of human and historical freedom is fascinating as well. For those of us who sometimes struggle within dysfunctional systems, like health care, government or corporate bureaucracy, the frequent criticisms of the systems of the early 19th century feel very apt.

Over and over again I felt myself both seen and called out. I deeply enjoyed the book and feel like it helped me see some elements of my life differently.

This audible version was ok. There are better versions.

The audio recording is broken

47hr/15min into this title it skips. Wtf Audible I paid for this. Fix yourself.

Very slow

Alan Munroe was a tad slow for my taste. I thought he could be a little faster with his narration. Not a fan of this performance if i am being honest. he is very good at male voices, so good in fact that even the women sound like men. his voice needs a little bit more training during the romance section of the text