1

“Our reasons are not prophets
When oft our fancies are.”
― William Shakespeare, The Two Noble Kinsmen

This play sits next to 'Pericles, The Two Gentlemen of Verona', 'Henry VIII', and 'Cymbeline' as one of my least favorite Shakespeare plays. Ugh. I'm not a fan of Shakespeare's collaborations (see 'Henry VIII') plus 'The Two Noble Kinsmen' is also just a bit boring.

The story is losely based on Chauser's 'A Knight's Tale', but Shakespeare puts the two cousin's in love with one woman and sets the story in Athens and Thebes. I think the failing of this tragedy stems from, surprisingly, the inability of the play to convince me (the reader) in the transformation of the cousins from noble cousins to jealous dicks. There just isn't a strong enough catelyst. My other major beef with the play, is there isn't enough Shakespeare in it. Not enough amazing lines. Not enough dance to the English.

Most scholars agree on the following division in the play:

Prologue - Fletcher
Act 1 - Shakespeare
Act 2.1 - Shakespeare
Act 2.2-2.6 Fletcher
Act 3.1-3.2 Shakespeare
Act 3 Fletcher
Act 4 Fletcher
Act 5.1 Shakespeare
Act 5.2 Fletcher
Act 5.3-5.4 Shakespeare
Epilogue - Fletcher

There is some disagreement about whether Shakespeare or Fletcher wrote the first 33 lines of Act 5. Think about THAT. That is Biblical level exegesis when scholars, nearly 400 years after the fact are still disputing a page of lines of a VERY minor play. That level of byzantine back and forth is worthy of a play, or at least a narrative poem.

7 persone l'hanno trovata utile

A great production

Production is amazing, with strong performances, and music. As far as Shakespeare goes, he can do no wrong in my book, and I love this play as well.

Great version of a very tough play.

This series of Shakespeare audiobooks is the best you were going to find these days. This is one of his roughest plays. Read while you listen to get the full gist of everything and you will be fine. For the new readers of Shakespeare do not beat yourself up if this text does not come easy to you it is one of the harder ones to decipher and one of his leash produced work but you will not find a better audiobook of it. The acting ability to play her as a production quality is top notch

A Not Bad Collaboration Play

I have been listening to some Shakespeare that I have never seen performed and did not recall reading. I read the complete works years ago, but had no memory whatsoever of this play. It is not bad, but it lacks any single compelling scene to latch onto. Most of the plays have at least one, and sometimes many, unforgettable monologs, dialogs, or narration. Alas, this play was enjoyable but unmemorable. I finished listening to this not long ago, and could provide an outline of the story and characters, but can't seem to recall my favorite scene. I suspect I will forget it again before long.

This is one of the "Shakespeare" plays that was written in collaboration. I tend to uniformly like the collaborations the least of as the "Shakespeare" plays.

This is not a great play to use as an introduction to Shakespeare.

The acting and narration, as well as the sound effects and music, were quite nice.

Solid Shakespeare Play

No my favorite Shakespeare play, the plot is a bit mundane, however the performance is outstanding and it helps me to round out my Shakespeare experience.

Outstanding Entertainment

I listened to the Arkangel audio while reading the play in E Book format from Delphi Complete Works of William Shakespeare. I found this play exceptionally enjoyable and entertaining. Quite a good amount of musical scores accompanied this production and the singing was outstanding. In the work two cousins are prisoners after a battle they participated in was lost and they both fall in love instantly with the same maiden. As the play proceeds there is betrayal, fighting and the jailers daughter becomes a bit of a mad person who goes about the town singing and acting foolish (well love does that to you I suppose). The cast of the production put in a delightful performance. Highly recommend enjoying Shakespeare this way.