Is There An Editor In The House??

There are plenty of excellent reviews here on audible for this book. As you can see by my lack of stars this wasn't for me. I have just a few thoughts to add here about the book. First, to me, it felt a bit like a collection of creative writing exercises that were just strung together into a book. There wasn't a clear voice that led the reader through this 20+ hour book. At times it almost felt like different writers were at work.

However, most importantly, before you decide on the book do an internet search for interviews done by Hill when the book was published. It is fascinating to hear the author's own words about his work. My biggest take away was that he tried to pack the book with everything that enraged, irritated, frustrated, and infuriated him in life. Put simply, it worked--he succeeded. As a result this "tragicomedy" is all those feelings wrapped up into one very long book.

Hill worried that he would only get to write one book in his life and he wanted to "say it all". I wish he would have had more faith in his writing skill and had said less? Oh, for the want of an editor. Tread carefully.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

200 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Nathan Hill is an exceptional storyteller.

In an interview about The Nix, Nathan Hill said, "I stuffed it full of every idea I had. It became a repository of things in the world I was mad about, concerned and confused about." Luckily for me as a reader, he was mad, concerned, and confused about college professors and students they have to deal with, plagiarism, MMORPGs, politics, media, mother-son relationships, past deeds that haunt us, and choose-your-own adventure books. At 620 pages it's a big repository, and even though there were times I wished it had been edited down, there were more times that I wished the stories would go on and on. I started listening to The Nix as an audiobook, but know that the hardcover version weighs in at 620 pages because I bought it when I came to the embedded choose-your-own-adventure book. While "You Can Get The Girl!" is not strictly based upon the readers' choices, I loved this, as I have often longed for this format written for adults.

Reviewers that were not as enthralled with this book as I was seemed to think that Nathan Hill was trying to say something about America and how it has evolved/devolved since the sixties, and that may well have been his intention. Rather than look for a message, I simply enjoyed the multiple story lines, full of humor, sadness, satire, details, and thoughts that point out how funny, terrible, and ludicrous life can be (with all them often occurring simultaneously), like this one from Walter Cronkite's mind:

"It's a chilling thought, that politicians have learned to manipulate the television medium better than the television professionals themselves. When old Cronkite first realized this was happening he imagined the kinds of people who would become politicians in the future. And he shuddered with fear."

It's only September, but I'm going to go out on a limb and say that The Nix is most likely the best book I'll read this year. Nathan Hill is an exceptional storyteller, and Ari Fliakos is the perfect narrator.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

151 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Simply awesome

Once I started I couldn't stop. Funny, endearing, dark and whimsical, there's something for everyone as we travel from the 60s to the 80s and modern day. I just love this book. It has tones of Owen Meaney while wrapping us up in a mystery. And we genuinely grow to care about the characters.

I'm only half through and I'm stopping briefly to let you all know, give The Nix a chance. It's not often I write a review and it's even more rare that I find a book this good. Half through and I'm already sad it's going to have to end as I know it'll be awhile before I find another book like this one.

The narrator, by the way, nails the voices abd brings life to all the characters. Simply superb.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

95 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Ari Fliakos is a phenomenal narrator!

I vacillated for days before pulling the trigger on this book - boy, am I glad I did! I laughed out loud, I sympathized with our hero(?) and cheered for the video-game geek! I'm not sure how this book would fare as a "read" book - Ari Fliakos ability to voice each of the characters truly brought them to life. I'm not usually a fan of satire, but this one was a delight!

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

78 persone l'hanno trovata utile

I gave it a good try

Part way through chapter 16, I gave up on this book. Up to that point, every scene was disturbing and more or less disgusting. (One scene returns repeatedly to a detailed description of a gob of phlegm slipping slowly down the protagonist's windshield as he drives in rush-hour traffic.) I cannot imagine another 17 hours and 27 minutes of this.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

52 persone l'hanno trovata utile

I adored this book and the narrator. Perfect.

Any additional comments?

Ari Fliakos's narration was outstanding. His rendition of Laura, the college student, was completely hilarious. I listened avidly to the entire book, even taking it with me while I walked the dog, because I couldn't stop listening. It was a wonderful romp, filled with great writing. It put me in mind of Donna Tartt's books. Thank you Nathan Hill, and thank you Ari Fliakos.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

49 persone l'hanno trovata utile

I tried. I really really tried

Would you try another book from Nathan Hill and/or Ari Fliakos?

When Audible proclaimed this book as the most popular of 2016, I went right for it. I really like the beginning with Samuel and Rachel dueling it out about a failing grade. But then characters entered the book, and had little scenarios with the author. Then characters came in and had scenarios with the other characters. I kept waiting for the book to pull together so that the circles of people coalesced into some, any, shared purpose. Instead the book turned into one continuous set of short stories, with random characters interacting, moving the small plot forward inch by agonizing inch.

I got 13 hours into it before calling it quits - which is a big commitment for a book I liked less and less as the chapters went on. Once again I used my criteria - "Do I care if most or any of the characters die on the next page?". Nope, after 13 hours they should have died a lot sooner.

What could Nathan Hill have done to make this a more enjoyable book for you?

Edited it by quite a bit. Maybe a 300 page book would have told the story more succinctly, and more successfully. Did he have an editor?

Which character – as performed by Ari Fliakos – was your favorite?

Interestingly enough shallow Rachel. Her observation about life as it was given her, her struggles to live that life in a real world, and her doubts about which is true. Alright, I don't wish Rachel was dead, I would like to know what the author did for her.

If you could play editor, what scene or scenes would you have cut from The Nix?

Scenes upon scenes upon scenes that did not move the plot forward or did not develop one of the many character's plight.

Any additional comments?

Better luck next time

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

47 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Loved it!

Closer to 4.5 stars! I loved this book! It was long but always engaging. I had to know how it all ended and the ending was perfect! It's all about choices and regrets and forgiveness (of self and others) and how it all drives you and enables you to make better ones in the future. It shows what a mess one can make out of life for the dumbest of reasons, but not the corny kinds of reasons that just make for a Laurel and Hardy kind of mess- the kinds you can relate to because you've done the same thing. The author puts you in the head of the characters so you understand their choices and empathize with them so that you care and root for them (or in the case of some, hate them and hope for their downfall). I will definitely be looking forward to the next book from this author! And the narrator, Ari Fliakos, did a fabulous job with the different voices for characters!

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

42 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Most annoying book I have ever read

Unbelievable and unlikeable characters. A ridiculous, convoluted plot.
Periodic, predictable rants from the main characters that are self-indulgent, long and BORING. This author was too cute by half.

Sorry I wasted my time. Don't waste yours- unless you go for this kind of tripe.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

39 persone l'hanno trovata utile

Pretty brilliant...

I loved this book but I can understand why the reviews are mixed because it would not be for everyone.

First off, it's not a sweet or heartwarming story. It's a clunky coming of age and never quite getting there story. The characters are flawed and confused and just downright crazy at times, but I thought it was masterful and I never lost interest.

While it's not even remotely political, if you are a law and order kind of person, you might find yourself a bit put off by the characters and the situations they find themselves in.

If you love books like Confederacy of Dunces (which was even more brilliant, I think), you might find yourself right at home with this quirky, surprisingly deep novel.

Listen to the sample (always listen to the sample) and if you laugh a few times, then buy the book.

Hai valutato questa recensione!

Hai segnalato questa recensione!

29 persone l'hanno trovata utile