Something is a little jarring

On paper, this is a book that I ought to have enjoyed given I like very similar books. However, I struggled to finish it, and when I did I was no longer invested.
The style where there are two narrators narrated by different people sounds like a good idea, but it gets really jarring when one does the other's voice as they're very different. Taken separately, the narrators do a good job; the switching is what raises the issue.

4 persone l'hanno trovata utile

One of my top books of the year!

If I could, I would give all the stars in the night sky to Bill Konigsberg and The Music of What Happens. This YA LGBT novel worked its way into my heart and refuses to let go. With a unique and refreshing cast of characters who aren’t afraid to recognize their shortcomings or tackle the problems life throws at them, this book is probably my top read of the year so far.

One of the real assets of this story was how REAL it was. It wasn’t a stereotypical “summer love” young adult novel. This book showed that sometimes, life sucks. Life is hard, lousy things happen to good people, and not everyone can deal in a constructive and healthy way.

But Max and Jordan forged an unlikely friendship which morphed into a fledgling love and learned to lean on each other, which I found heartwarming and beautiful. I loved that they were able to open up to each other and become a source of strength for one another. My momma bear instincts kicked into overdrive for these two and I have adopted Jordan as my fictional son and want to take care of him forever.

The Music of What Happens deals with some heavy topics and honestly, certain parts were difficult to read. My heart hurt for these boys, especially as I could draw some parallels between their experiences to my own youth (back when the dinosaurs still roamed the earth). But I felt they were handled respectfully and thoughtfully.

I listened to the audiobook (of course), and the narration was outstanding. Anthony Rey Perez was a new narrator for me, and he embodied Max perfectly. Joel Froomkin is, well…Joel. Need I say more? If you’ve known me more than a minute, you know my feelings there. Of course, he nails the main characters, but even beyond that, his portrayal of Jordan’s “wives” had me snort-laughing so many times throughout the story. He made even those “secondary” characters so vivid and entertaining, I loved them and couldn’t help but become attached to them.

Konigsberg wrote a story that was heartwarming and silly and serious and authentic and wonderful. I don’t have enough superlatives to describe how I felt about this book. I honestly loved it and feel it truly is a book that so many people, young, old, gay, straight, and anything in between could benefit from reading.

2 persone l'hanno trovata utile

The story was right up my street. One of the narrators slightly ruined my experience though

Nice story. I particularly liked the character Max his approach to life was something I would like to imitate, always cool and collected. Jordan practically the opposite I just didn’t connect to. I think I might have found him cuter if the narrator hadn’t been so over the top. Sure his character was termed “dramatic” but he did over use the !!!! 100%. For all the characters as well, even J’s mom had the “OMG!” factor which made no sense because why would she talk like the teenagers do? I found myself turning the volume down when his chapters came on (it was like he was shouting into the microphone) and then turning them up again for Max who was just so much more pleasant to listen to. Even when Jordan was talking in Max’s chapters the narrator for Max made Jordan alot more tolerable than he was in his own chapters. I was determined to finish the story as it had a good story but I have to admit I did almost stop from how much cringe Jordan’s chapters were. He just came across less likeable and at times I even questioned what Max saw him really. I think that was 99% the narrator that made me feel that way. Sorry but thats the truth.

1 persona l'ha trovata utile

Touching story

Flawed-but-likeable characters, engaging performances, a deftly-plotted storyline with touching/tender moments, humour and believable character development.

1 persona l'ha trovata utile

Very up and down story

It’s an ok story. I must admit the first half was quite good I enjoyed the flirting and the when will they sort of vibe the book had, however the second half is very dark. I know that the world can be dark at times of course but I feel there’s so very harsh tones in what the two boys have been through which I personally feel should have some discretionary warning. The second half lacks the light enjoyable escape you often wish to find in a book.

wonderful

The actors read their parts so well and the story is wonderful. Focusing on many different and difficult topics. I want a sequel!!

Incredible!

I really loved this book. Brilliant, deep characters...excellent narration.... fabulous writing. Take the plunge. Read it.

Just... wow!

I really enjoyed. The actors voices were enjoyable to listen to and the story was captivating, raw, real and just fantastic.
Thank you for the many hours of enjoyable listening. x

Beautiful

This was a lovely book to listen to.
I’m not going to lie it did seam to drag on a bit but I’d rather have a longer book than something that was over too quickly.
The actors(?) were great. I was beginning to find one voice a bit too much at times but I suppose that was the way it was written (sorry Joel!). It would have been nice to have changed between the different guys when it was them talking (not just their chapter).

Overall happy to have listened to this audiobook, made my drives to work more enjoyable.
I managed not to cry though there were some points I nearly did. (Surprised myself that I’m not a heartless monster 😂)

So many emotions

I’ve listened to some Bill Konigsberg books before and this did not disappoint. It was a rollercoaster of emotions that I was not expecting to go on. Amazing depth of characters and well read by both!! Worth a listen to!!