Steuver's portraits are at once humane, heartfelt, revealing - and very, very funny. Tinsel is a compelling tale of our half-trillion-dollar holiday, measuring what we've become against the ancient rituals of what we've always been.
I thoroughly enjoyed this book, especially as it was a refreshing change from the usual current holiday glurge. The author seems to give an honest picture of the families he followed, treating them with respect, affection, and humor. I think he did a pretty good job of capturing, from an outsider's perspective, what we all want Christmas to be, how we try to go about making it happen, and how it can sometimes fall short of that dream. He completely nailed Stonebriar Mall, Frisco, a certain type of affluent North Texas demographic, and Canton. I laughed out loud at his description of Canton, remembering my own WTF-moment when I saw the scooter-people last time I was there. My only criticism is his seemingly hurried treatment of the last two years of the book. He really only covers a single Christmas - 2006 - and just checks in and gives us an update of the 2007 and 2008 Christmases. It's unfortunate, because he was in a unique position to thoroughly document how the changing economy impacted our attitudes between those years. I remember 2008 as the year we could no longer pretend that there wasn't something seriously wrong with the economy, and that Christmas as especially black. But I suppose it wasn't *that* kind of a book.
Ray Porter's reading was excellent. He lent a dry tone of voice to the text that seemed just right, and he gave a pretty good approximation of the Texas drawl. Most audiobook narrators seem to substitute a southern accent for Texans.
30 su 31 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
I really enjoyed this book! Narration was fantastic, it was read with feeling. I liked hearing about the lives of those people living in Frisco, TX. This book gave me an overall general view of what I hope Christmas to be but always falls short of-way short. I understand my desire for a beautiful fire, a table laden with goodies from my childhood and a family that's truly thankful. But the author is right, we can't go back. This book has actually helped me to come to terms with my disappointment every season. Perhaps, perhaps, I won't feel that longing next Christmas. Now that would be absolutely phenomenal!
28 su 30 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
The book is interesting enough, but if there are real truths about the holiday season tucked inside I missed them.
26 su 34 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
I never would have bought this book except it was an Audible Daily Deal and I listened to the sample. I try to not be that influenced by titles or covers, but it happens. Tinsel is about so much more than decorations, Black Friday or Christmas. Witty author; fantastic narrator. Never heard of the author (how could this be after looking him up!), but will look for his other book, Off-ramp.
1 su 1 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
Highly recommended book that tracks how a few families observe Christmas in their TX community. Observations come from just before, and right after, the economic woes of 2008. The author also includes just enough history and statistics to cover America in general. The whole thing could come off as overly cynical if not for the author's own confessions of a Christmas he seems to long for and can't quite achieve or even fully recall.
1 su 1 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
This is a wry, funny, and touching look at our Christmas pastime. I listen to it every year. The narrator, too, is “absolutely phenomenal !”
It's not your average Christmas Story, not a lot to laugh at, but real. It will keep me in perspective with how much money I spend for Christmas. Maybe I should listen to it every year.
All in all a good listen but author was a little snide and his judgment ever sent and harsh.
2 su 4 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
This is definitely not a holiday cheer book. it does show how materialistic our world has become and does give you pause to what is truly important
1 su 3 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
If you are atheist or just not believing in Jesus is the reason for the Eason you may like this book. It takes apart and dis values Christmas.
2 su 7 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
Where does Tinsel rank among all the audiobooks you’ve listened to so far?
I really enjoyed it. I wanted something to listen to that was about Christmas and took the plunge. It was definitely up there with the greats. Its a slice of an American Christmas, following a few characters across three years. Luckily for the author the first year of his project was 2006 when everyone thought the good times were here to stay. The following years briefly catch up on the residents of Frisco as the effects of the Credit Crunch are beginning to tell.
Who was your favorite character and why?
Jeff Trykowski the Christmas light's wizard. Because this is an audiobook there are obviously no photographs so I entered Jeff's name in Youtube and...wow! They are stunning!
Have you listened to any of Ray Porter’s other performances? How does this one compare?
Ray Porter is fast becoming my favourite narrator. I've just finished listening to his reading of They Thirst. This is a factual book but he still imbues the participants with a great selection of easily recognisable voices. I'm going to start looking at his back catalogue.
Did you have an emotional reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
I love Christmas, as most of the people in this book do, so it definitely gave me a glow. There are sad bits and funny bits.
Any additional comments?
A prescient look at how Christmas is celebrated in a boom town in Texas. It touches on the history of Christmas in America, the economics of the festive period and the religious side too, through a cast of mainly sympathetic characters. It exposes the commercial side of the festive season mercilessly, but boils everything down to the important things. A nice easy listen. I'd really recommend it for your December credit.