"Macintosh" is a taut psychological study of two officials on a remote tropic island. "The Fall of Edward Barnard" is a brief bildungsroman about what is important in life, a pre-cursor to Maugham's well known novel, The Razor's Edge. Of course, love is always a subject of the tropics, and Maugham's deft, ironic handling of the theme in "Red" and "Honolulu" is masterful. But it is "The Pool" that tells a poignant and tragic tale about the pitfalls for love across cultures. His most famous story, "Rain", about the ironic consequences of obsession, was adapted for both theater and film.
I have long been a fan of Maugham, and looked forward to listening to this collection of some of his best short stories. Alas, the whole experience was dampened by the desultory and unemotional reader, who seemed so lazy or perhaps bored by the stories. Many readers found in Audible selections have a good ability to change their voices to indicate the various characters,but Davidson here only seemed to manage a hoarse and harsh tone. The choice of reader is really a pity, for these stories offer intriguing characters, and life choices with moral imlications relevant even today, when British colonials have gone the way of the dinosaurs. Thus, I can only offer a limited recommendation for this book.
1 su 1 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
I'm afraid the reader Frederick Davidson(David Case) made it impossible to complete this book. There were many words slurred and impossible to understand. It's as if this reader has now had a stroke or some other debilitating speech impediment. I feel compelled to write this review because I am such a fan of audiobooks and audible and I would hate to think someone would buy this book and get turned off from audiobooks and or audible. Audible please consider removing this book from your Library - you have so many wonderful books, why taint it.
6 su 10 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
These are some of Maugham's tales of the south Pacific. These unflinching, unpredictable stories are why literature exists. The narrator, Frederick Davidson, may not be to everybody's taste. He reads as if it is the the first time he has seen the text and occasionally he swallows the ends of words.
But that is not the main problem.
All the stories in this collection are found in W. S. Maugham's "Rain and Other Stories", narrated by Steven Crossley which contains seven others. Save your credit/money and get that one instead.
What made the experience of listening to The Trembling of a Leaf the most enjoyable?
One gets the impression the reader's rather exaggerated tone is almost a send up of the story, but yet his reading his very effective and engging. Thoroughly enjoyed the story and the reading.
What does Frederick Davidson bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
clarity and he understands and conveys the import of Maugham's words.
Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?
I use this book to help me get to sleep. It's very disconnected.
Would you be willing to try another book from W. Somerset Maugham? Why or why not?
I don't think I'll be trying another Maugham novel.
Did the narration match the pace of the story?
The narration is fine.
Do you think The Trembling of a Leaf needs a follow-up book? Why or why not?
No, it doesn't need a follow-up. It needs a guide book.
Any additional comments?
It's so disappointing to use points and not like the book.
1 su 4 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione