Dickens provides another memorable cast of characters, including the dull-witted, tyrannical John Willet, Dennis the Hangman, and Hugh the savage ostler.
"Barnaby Rudge" is possibly Dickens's least well-known novel among modern readers. Hollywood has ignored it: there's a 1915 silent film version, a 1960 BBC version, and that's it. There are reasons for this: the novel makes an awkward 5-year jump in the middle, sends major characters off-stage for hundreds of pages, and is in general more padded with extraneous material and long conversations than it needs to be. Even if you're a Dickens fan, you might prefer an abridged version as an audiobook.
But the full version has its rewards. Over time, characters who initially seemed flat and stereotyped take on true psychological depth. The best of them are among the best in Dickens--no one has created a better picture of genteel hypocrisy than Sir John Chester, for example. There are magnificent descriptions of 18th-century inns and an imaginative recreation of London after dark, pre-gaslight. And the historical portions, the depiction of Lord Gordon, the rioters, and the anarchy they unleash on London, are as compelling as the better-known counterparts in "Tale of Two Cities".
Whitfield's narration and voice characterization is excellent throughout, despite a couple of annoying idiosyncrasies (notably, the way he handles "Why" as an exclamation). Audio quality of the file is excellent (enhanced format).
17 su 19 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
Lighter characters are not as prominent as in better known Dickens' novels, so this is not as heart warming as usual; however, I thought it just as good as any Dickens and, as an historical tale, I liked it better than "Tale of Two Cities." There is less domestic melodrama, but the usual Dickens' cast of characters and stereotypes: overbearing-martyr-complex wife, shrew, feral young man, sensible young woman, beautiful but silly young woman, honourable rich young man, put-upon striving poor young man, and not one but two selfish, narcissistic fathers -- And Barnaby. And Grip -- all embroiled in political and social machination.
Dickens' usual insight into human nature is sharp thoughout: "So do the shadows of our own desires stand between us and our better angels" -- No psychologist ever described projection, scapegoating, mob mentality, and political manipulation as well as well as Dickens does in "Barnaby Rudge."
Most characters still live happily ever after in the end, however, as the spoiler in the publisher's summary suggests.
Whitfield's narration is excellent as usual.
(And this is a must listen for all fans of ravens, literary or avian.)
13 su 16 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
This was a long story, with many characters. I lost parts of the story along my commute as there are numerous conversations with the characters, which didn't appear to have meaning, but come together in the end. I had to relisten to parts of the book to keep up with the story. The narrator was fantastic with his ability to change characters manners and age which is part of Dickens work. I preferred the end of the book much more as that is where the riots and drama evolves. It lacked some of the mystery of his famous classical works like Twist and Great Expectations, but to me the last 20 chapters brought it all together. The characters and accents were excellently done with the likes of Dennis the Hangman, and the Gabriel the locksmith, the idiot Barnaby, and almost human Grip. If you like Dickens you should like this one.
4 su 5 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
The comforting literary superfluities one comes to expect in a Dickens novel are present in full force in Barnaby Rudge. A good history lesson peopled by interesting characters and detailed story line. A great book, by a great author, read by a great narrator. What more can one hope for. Highly recommended.
2 su 3 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
Out of all the audiobook narrators I have listened to, including Messrs. Timson & Lesser, Simon Vance is by far the best. He brings every character to life, especially in this one. His reading of Barnaby's speech accurately reflects the character's simplicity of mind.
Dickens is an awesome storyteller and Simon Vance really nails the narration. Long but interesting throughout
A Dickens novel is always an enjoyable read, and this book gives a very good historical account of the Gordon riots.
This is certainly the least successful of Dickens' novels, and thus of interest only to the dedicated Dickens reader.
Simon Vance is best at narrating the story, but is poor when it comes to dramatizing the characters, especially the women. His "voices" are emphatically artificial.
0 su 1 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
The narration and story are excellent, but there are a number of faults in the recording in the second the third files. These have been reported to audible (they have verified and acknowledge that there are errors in the files) but I see that they continue to have this for sale. Please note that, if you choose to buy this, it will not be perfect. You will be able to listen to the whole story but there will be jumps in the narration at places. I have given one star to draw attention to this problem.
3 su 3 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
Great narration by Simon Vance throughout and an entertaining and informative story. Some great satire, observations and philosophy and some tense, exciting action. Just takes a while to get going compared to some other Dickens stories