This is a tale of two tragedies.
At the heart of the first is Dr. Steven Hayne, a doctor the State of Mississippi employed as its de facto medical examiner for two decades. Beginning in the late 1980s, he performed anywhere from 1,200 to 1,800 autopsies per year, five times more than is recommended, performed at night in the basement of a local funeral home. Autopsy reports claimed organs had been observed and weighed when, in reality, they had been surgically removed from the body years before. But Hayne was the only game in town. He also often brought in local dentist and self-styled "bite mark specialist" Dr. Michael West, who would discover marks on victim's bodies, at times invisible to the naked eye, and then match those marks - "indeed and without doubt" - to law enforcement's lead suspect.
This leads to the second tragic tale: that of Kennedy Brewer and Levon Brooks, two black men each convicted in separate cases of the brutal rape and murder of young girls. Dr. Hayne's autopsy and Dr. West's bite-mark matching formed the bases for the convictions. Combined, the two men served over 30 years in Mississippi's notorious penitentiary - Parchman Farm - before being exonerated in 2008. Brooks' and Brewer's wrongful convictions lie at the intersection of both the most pressing problem facing this country's criminal justice system - structural injustice built on the historic foundation of race and class as well as with the much more contemporary but equally egregious problem of invalid forensic science. The old problem is inextricably bound up with and exacerbates the new.
In The Cadaver King and the Country Dentist, Radley Balko and Tucker Carrington write a true story of Southern Gothic horror - of two innocent men wrongly convicted of vicious crimes and the legally condoned failures that allowed it to happen. Balko and Carrington will shine a light on the institutional and professional failures that allowed this tragic, astonishing story to happen, identify where it may have happened elsewhere, and show how to prevent it from happening again.
If you've read the Publisher's Summary, you'll know what this book is about in its entirety.
Personally, I was hoping for a bit more about the "cadaver king" and the "country dentist" because when the authors write about them, it's a horror-show, period. Their behavior, their actions, their absolute lack of conscience, are astounding. Their misdeeds are breathtaking in scope. All of it will have you on the edge of your seat, madder 'n a wet hen.
But then the book is also about structural biases, how justice can be miscarried, a plethora of bite-sized examples which, don't get me wrong, are fascinating, but they rather wander here and there some of the time, and my mind rather wandered here and there with them. And then we go back to the meat of the story, and it's "indeed and without a doubt" a gripping listen.
Absolutely worth the time; absolutely worth the credit! Not since Bryan Stevenson's "Just Mercy" have I pondered the justice system so much.
8 su 9 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
I highly anticipated the release of this book and was not disappointed. As a native of Mississippi I believe the story is told with honest and intelligent research. A must for Nonfilction listeners!
4 su 5 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione
Would you listen to The Cadaver King and the Country Dentist again? Why?
I don't know that I'd listen to it again, it's not that kind of a book, but it's an excellent book and CLEARLY documents the fallacies and injustices in both Missouri and the larger US legal system.
What was one of the most memorable moments of The Cadaver King and the Country Dentist?
The end - tying it all together, showing how the legal system votes in their favor with scientific evidence, but votes against defendants consistently. This book exposes just how evil Steven Hayne, Michael West, Jim Hood (still attorney General of Alabama!), & Forrest Allgood (DA) are. How their desire to not look bad has kept innocent men in Jail, how they have said one thing to the press and actually taken actions that repudiate what they just stated. Horrific that we as a society allow this to happen in the US. If you have read this book and not been shocked or disturbed, you've failed to understand its implications.
What does Robert Fass bring to the story that you wouldn’t experience if you just read the book?
Mr. Fass has a good clear voice that is easy to listen to and added to the book
Did you have an extreme reaction to this book? Did it make you laugh or cry?
Mostly cry - it's horrific what happened to these people and how the State of Mississippi has constantly sought to obfuscate or deny justice.
Any additional comments?
If you have an interest in criminal justice reform, read this book.
the best part was how the authors put the situation in perspective. framing the story as part of Mississippi s history of racism and using the legal system to uphold and enforce social norms. truth, science, and justice are not priorities
This book is very fact and figures heavy.
It is worth a listen, conversely though it isn’t a page turner. With most books I download I can’t put them down, this was not particularly captivating.
That being said, it is totally shocking that what’s reported in the book actually did happen.