Emily Fox-Seton: The Making of a Marchioness and The Methods of Lady Walderhurst

Cinderella and Her Almost Handsome Prince

Having read this book quite a few times over the years, I was pleased to find it in Audible's library. My hat is off to the producers. The names of the narrators weren't included but they were fabulous. I especially liked the announcer who obviously was kidnapped from the BBC World Service. The woman who did the story narration had a lovely expressive voice. The little music clips closing the chapters were a nice touch. Burnett had a thing for India. In many ways, it became a kind of character in a number of her books including "A Little Princess", "The Secret Garden" and this title. It is a place of fantastical mystery, unknown splendor and sudden terrifying dangers, where both death and wonder lurked in shadows. As the synopsis suggested, this is an adult fairy tale. Burnett's early life was no fairy tale so her stories have a firm basis in hard reality which is appealing and believable. Who better to tell the story of Cinderella before the fairy godmother and the prince than one who has lived Cinderella's life? Emily Fox Seton struck me as a Catherine Morland ("Northanger Abbey") type of heroine with an innocent belief in the goodness of fellow human beings. It was no great surprise when Emily loved the dry, distant Lord Walderhurst enough for both. She needed someone to love; he needed a wife who would leave him in peace. I really enjoyed the way this unsophisticated woman handled herself when confronted with the attempts against her life. If I remember my Austen, I think Henry Tillney fell in love with Catherine because she was so much in love with him. In like fashion, cold, self-centered Walderhurst found himself in love with Emily because she so absolutely loved him. Is the book as good as "A Little Princess" or "The Secret Garden"? No, but most books aren't that good, yet I still manage to enjoy quite a few of them.

11 su 11 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione

Great Fun!

Not suprisingly, since this is Frances Hodges Burnette, there is a fairy tale element to this story. I have long been a fan of her children's books but had no idea she'd written a fairy tale for adults in effect! It is a fun and engaging narrative and, even though set over a hundred years ago, in Edwardian England, is suprisingly sophisticated in its psychological observations and "modern" elements in the drama. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

And I found the narration just fine. There are actually two separate narrators for the male and female voices and, while this can distract at times, it also works well at others. And I did find that the female narrator made a satisfactory distinction between the British female voices and the several American female characters. Well enough done, in my opinion to add to the story rather than detracting.

6 su 6 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione

Story lovely, delivery is flawed

Book: This is my first book by F.H.Burnett and I enjoyed it very much. It would be easy to write it off as light without looking at the effect Emily has on the lives around her. She has the ability to transform, made more interesting as it is set in a staid period and society. The racial and gender generalizations are unsavory but the author seems to be using conventions of the time and not postulating they are accurate.
Delivery: This really detracts from the book. It is set in England, and the correct accent should be correctly applied to the proper characters. The male characters are well done but there is a tendency to "overact" the female characters which makes it sound more targeted for a child audience. This can make the story itself appear more simple than it is.
Overall, I would recommend listening as it's the only version available.

1 su 1 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione

Charming Story, Flawed Delivery

This is an engaging Edwardian story. Unfortunately, the main narrator is quite off the mark. She engages accents for the lead characters that appear devoid of any rhyme or reason. For example, only one of the women in the story is presented with a British accent, although all are clearly very English. So, as enjoyable a story as it is, be prepared, the presentation grates.

There is also some racist descriptions within the storyline, which are offputting. Probably less controversial in context of the period writing, however, still jarring in today's world.

1 su 1 utenti hanno ritenuto utile questa recensione

Old and valuable.

Yes this is dated, novels of manners are intended to portray a time and place and the attitudes of the characters of that time and place. Thus this couple and their intimates are not us. The story is delightful and you will not forget the people you meet. Well played and more!

Not as Great as her Children’s Books

Nothing will beat, for me, the first time I read The Secret Garden. I loved that book and I went on to collect many of her children’s books and a few of her ‘adult’ books. These are very simplistic and Not at all pc. I don’t just mean the occasional racist remark, sadly Burnett was a woman of her time. (I personally think it’s better to leave these things in the books so that we will learn from them, but I was raised by very liberal parents. I don’t think anyone will smoke because there Was a cigarette in the room with the Moon!) Anyway this book has the same ‘good-hearted will win the day’ theme as her child heroes and heroines. It’s enjoyable as a piece of history and I certainly had a wonderful time with it, but I cannot believe it would interest tweens or adult readers unless they know what they are getting. If you want a lovely, very old fashioned style story then this is fine. If you go nuts when characters behave as they would have- or say something we’d Never even Think, well this is not for you. Still great download for Grandmother if she is old fashioned and you have a long ride there and back again!

Period piece

Would you say that listening to this book was time well-spent? Why or why not?

I enjoy this kind of story, though not as a steady diet. But do yourself a favor and get the other version. The main reader here was irritating beyond belief.

Has Emily Fox-Seton: The Making of a Marchioness and The Methods of Lady Walderhurst turned you off from other books in this genre?

Nope

Who would you have cast as narrator instead of various?

Almost any English-born actress.

If this book were a movie would you go see it?

Only if the costumes/setting were exceptional