In this high-stakes horror showdown, Pablo and Sebastian pit two time-loop slashers against each other: the college-comedy-horror hit Happy Death Day (2017) and the 2025 film adaptation of the hit PlayStation game, Until Dawn. From exploding water to immortal sisters and the mystery of "Who is Bill Murray?", our hosts dissect which movie utilizes the loop best and which one deserves to be deleted from filmmaking history forever.

Timestamps:

• 00:05 - Introduction to the Time Loop Horror Series.

  
  

• 02:29 - Cast breakdown: Jessica Rothe vs. Ella Rubin.

  
  

• 07:13 - The "Until Dawn" Game vs. Movie: Why the rewind mechanic changes everything.

  
  

• 09:09 - Round 2: Why Tree Gelbman is the modern-day Phil Connors.

  
  

• 14:00 - Visuals: The mysterious "Wall of Rain" and underground mining towns.

  
  

• 22:05 - WTF Moment: The infamous "Exploding Water" deaths.

  
  

• 31:39 - Plot Holes: Wendigo transformations and Peter Stormare’s confusing role.

  
  

• 37:24 - The Final Verdict: Which movie gets deleted?

  
  

After six grueling rounds and three wildcards, Happy Death Day takes the crown. While Until Dawn showed visual potential, its ridiculous plot holes and "ridiculous" creature transformations led to its ultimate deletion.

• Happy Death Day is currently free in Youtube Movies

  
  

• Until Dawn (2025) is available in Netflix.